[alnorth]

I believe Geno probably is BPA.

When you are grading players, obviously you grade on a curve based on position. To illustrate that, if we had a guy in the draft who was regarded as the very best kicker in the entire decade, there is no way he'd go early, probably not even the first round. He would not be BPA, because that position is not as valuable.

The lack of a good QB is utterly devastating to a team without one, and this is not like kickers where the worst kicker really isn't that much worse than the best, the dropoff from the best to the 2nd-tier QB's in the draft is huge. Some people are acting like Geno is clearly a 2nd-day player, but he isn't. He's a first-round player in any draft, including last year.