Quote:
Originally Posted by MagicHef
Since she's willing to hang people for crimes they didn't commit, I'm thinking she's willing to go there.
I know you guys are clinging to her resurrection being somehow vastly different than the only other similar resurrection we've seen, but I'm going to go with the evidence the books have provided, and say Stoneheart is ~95% Catelyn.
|
Your assertion that Stoneheart is 95% Catelyn is way, way, way off. I would say closer to 5%. It seems all Stoneheart has of Catelyn is a notion of who wronged her family and her only goal is retribution.
Catelyn's resurrection is very different from Beric's because she was dead for probably days before resurrection. Beric was resurrected within minutes each time and even he was slightly different. They basically said in the book that Catelyn was probably too far gone to resurrect but they did it anyway.