Quote:
Originally Posted by Marcellus
Gotcha.
I think SOC proved last year that you don't have to have faith in the FO to be a good fan once that FO has proven inadequate. IN that case being a good fan meant voicing your displeasure loud enough to make an impact.
However railing on a FO that hasn't shown any propensity to be incompetent is kind of silly.
The Giants are well run organization. If you read that whole blog the guy isn't that harsh on the move IMO anyway.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marcellus
I think CP's belief in value of 2nd round picks is exaggerated.
They gave up 1 too many 2nd rounders I agree. No need to lose your shit over a 2nd round pick though.
|
I think these two statements are at odds with one another.
Carl Peterson and Scooter Pioli sucked at drafting with their 2nd round picks. They also both made big errors in trading for and relying on other teams' leftovers at the QB position.
If you give Dorsey the benefit of the doubt on the QB thing, don't you ALSO have to give him the benefit of the doubt on the 2nd round pick?