Quote:
Originally Posted by Mecca
Yea well look at this buddy.....Limas Sweed is one that I really really don't like. I don't like Talib either..
It's just not good you picked players that don't work. You take take questionable players like that. It's a deep corner year and Talib is a bad 1st rounder and I just personally hate Sweed and this is a horrid WR draft.
|
Don't work? Isn't Herm running a cover 2? Doesn't he want big corners? Sweed fits the Chiefs mold for big receivers and has all the tools with huge upside, if provided some good coaching. Also, taking him would be predicated on a clean bill of health. Look here buddy:
Sweed:
Positives: Has a tall, well-built and rare-sized frame, with proportioned muscles, good chest and upper body development, nice arm length, large hands and developed legs and calves … Has the straight-line speed and acceleration needed to be effective in the vertical passing game … Not a precise route runner, but his long stride helps him compensate and eat up the defender's cushion … Possesses good quickness and change-of-direction agility, along with excellent leaping ability, but he must improve his timing competing for jump balls … Fluid in his stride, showing the body control and the ability to adjust to the ball in flight … Has the arm extension and flexibility to elevate and make the acrobatic catches … Has good field awareness and is alert to coverages and locating the soft areas underneath … Displays good toughness and leadership, working hard in practices and studying tapes to gain advantage over his opponents … Has that extra gear needed to gain advantage coming off the snap (when he doesn't try to get into battles with the press defender) … Smooth into his routes and will get physical with the defender in route progression (feels every thrown ball is his) … Strong runner who might not run crisp routes, but has the natural burst and quickness to separate … Uses his long stride well to quickly close a defender's cushion, and while he still needs refinement here, when he drops his weight while making cuts he generates much better foot quickness … Needs to figure out how to beat the jam with other moves, but can overpower a smaller defender … Does a nice job of settling in the short area and has the awareness with good body control to work himself free from a crowd … Talented receiver on the boundary, as he is good at finding throwing lanes for his quarterback when attacking the zone … Does gather some in his routes, but flashes good ability to adjust to the coverage, doing a nice job of uncovering … Natural adjuster to off-line throws and can make a great catch while keeping his feet along the sidelines … Displays good ball skills and hands when hauling in the ball with defenders draped on him (will lose concentration at times, but it is not from a lack of courage) … Not the type who will double or body catch, as he is very effective at using his reach to extend for the ball and does a good job of looking the pass in over his outside shoulder … The thing you see on film is his ability to execute the comeback and stay square going for the ball … Has good reaction quickness to look the ball in and will not hesitate to assert himself in order to run unimpeded down the sidelines … Can pluck the ball outside of his frame and make the tough catches … Has the speed and acceleration to stretch the field vertically and the balls skills necessary to haul in the deep pass … Must do a better job of timing his leaps, but he has the flexibility to adjust for the high, low and behind tosses … Likes to overpower defenders after the catch, but does have nifty moves to elude (just doesn't use them often) … Strong runner, especially when he catches the ball in front of the defender.
Negatives: Has excellent size and good strength, but he is not a face-up blocker and tends to shy away from contact when asked to lead block on sweeps and outside runs … Has had several problems with his left wrist that forced him to undergo mid-season surgery in 2007 and further medical evaluation is advised … Has a very fluid running stride, but is raw in his route running technique and needs to refine his plant-and-drive agility coming out of breaks (takes soft angle cuts, at times) … Also needs to show better stop-and-go action, as he will take a few false steps when trying to redirect back to the quarterback … Breaks off his routes too early when trying to get separation, and while he has a good reach he spends too much time trying to overpower press coverage defenders rather than trying to slip past and avoid … Also likes to combat with the defenders down field in attempts to get them out of their backpedal early, but it also ends up slowing down his route progression … Has had a history of concentration problems which prevents him from getting proper position to make the catch … Must do a better job of looking the ball in and securing it before trying to run with it (leads to dropped balls) … Has good leaping ability, but shows poor timing and arm extension trying to battle for jump balls (left 20 of 39 passes thrown to him behind in 2007) … More of a straight-line runner who can get under the pass nicely running straight-line routes, but lacks the loose hips to get a clean break and is more apt to break arm tackles rather than elude the defender in the open … For some reason, he failed to drop his weight and keep his feet working through pattern progression in 2007.
Compares To: ANDRE JOHNSON-Houston … While Sweed is taller than Johnson and Johnson has better separation ability, both are long striders with a good burst off the line vs. a clean release. He is quick to gobble up the cushion and get behind the defender, but he is not the most polished route runner you will find. With his size and ability to shield the ball from defenders, he does a fine job of getting to the ball in a crowd. However, he must show better concentration skills, as he has left quite a few thrown balls on the ground. When out in front of the defense, he can take the ball to the house, evident by his 20 touchdown catches. If he gets a clean bill of health leading up to the draft,
he will be able to secure first-day draft status.
Talib:
Scouting Report
The Good: Talib was a fixture in the Jayhawks’ secondary since his true freshman season, earning Big 12 honors each year. Talib shows playmaking ability in coverage and plays a gambling style that has produced big plays for each side. He is an agile athlete with long arms and good footwork. He moves well, and has shown the ability to play in either man or zone coverage. He is a well-built athlete who has bulked up over the past year and checked in at just under 6-foot-1 and 202 pounds after playing in the 185-pound range during his career.
The Bad: He is not a physical defender, and he can be hesitant to come up and support the run. He is only an average tackler who struggles getting off blockers and rarely delivers a big hit. He has the quickness to play man coverage against NFL-caliber talent, though he needs further development in his reads and responsibilities within a scheme.
Outlook: He looks like a top-40 prospect after his strong final season. He is still raw in some areas of coverage, and he may need a little time to refine his game before being a full-time starter.
However, he has the package to make that adjustment within a short time. He could disappoint in a situation where he has to start as a rookie and play on an island in man coverage. He is a fine prospect who probably falls to the early second round.