Quote:
Originally Posted by Reaper16
That is Saccopoo-level wrong. Wow. Sorry for the insult but it needs to be said.
At bare minimum, the fact that the events you waive away as part of Jack's mind are events that aired on the TV show act as specific reasons your interpretation might be wrong. Beyond that, we've been told repeadtedly in dialogue that "whatever happened, happened" and not just from Christian Shepard in the finale. It was said multiple times and was even an episode title. There is a veritable mountain of specific reasons to support that the on-island events actually physically happened to these characters.
|
And I disagree.
I don't think there's ANY proof that they happened, just as I don't think they "created a purgatory" for themselves in Season Six.
The only "proof" is that it was shown on network television.
But that in itself isn't enough to convince me that 60 people miraculously landed on a lush tropical island alive after dropping more than 35,000 feet in the air, only to find Egyptian ruins, the Dharma Initiative and a pair of Machiavellian immortals.