It's hard to judge with the injury and all. I would say if Berry didn't get hurt and the gap between 2010 and how he is playing now was the same great play, I give the edge to Berry. He is a little weaker in coverage, but I think I would take Berry if given a choice. Chancellor and coaching are two advantages Thomas has had so far. Not to mention not being taken out by a cheap shot that set you back a year and a half.
|