Quote:
Originally Posted by milkman
I think Manning was ascending, but I don't know that he hasn't hit a plateau.
I think he is about wher he will be, a fringe top 10 QB who can fall out of that level if a couple of QBs put together a couple of good seasons back to back.
I don't totally agree with Jason, but I think there is some merit to his point that Manning shouldn't have declined nearly as much as he did with the loss of Burress.
There is just something lacking in Manning's makeup that leads me to believe he's never going to be much more than he is right now.
|
Well I think Palmer's better but I'm not going to put him in the top 10 after only playing in a couple games last year. I'm giving Brady the benefit because of how much far ahead of everyone he was before his injury outside of Peyton.
The hate some people have for Palmer amazes me.