|
I never claimed Lady Stoneheart was not Catelyn, that was others. And I don't think it is incredible (or even hard) to justify her killing Freys. Um, they kind of deserve it! Hello?
The second part of your post makes no sense, Are you trying to say that if we saw more of Catelyn she'd be doing a bunch of stuff just as bad as Cersei? There is no basis for that conclusion. She appears to be hunting and killing Freys. Again, they deserve it. Arguably she is an instrument of the gods in this regard as she was brought back to life for some purpose. The Rat cook story shows the importance of guest right in Westeros. The gods turned the cook into a rat not because he killed and served the king's own son to him in a meat pie, but because he violated guest right.
Prior to Catelyn becoming Lady Stoneheart, your argument would be as dumb as can be. Once she becomes Lady Stoneheart bent on revenge, she enters more questionable moral grounds granted, but she is still nowhere close to Cersei in terms of purely bad things done. Nowhere close.
|