Quote:
Originally Posted by MagicHef
So you disagree with Thoros' assessment of their activities?
I'm saying that we have no idea how many people Catelyn has murdered, but we'd know of more if she appeared in the books more.
Cersei certainly has a wider range of bad things on her resume. However, incest, false accusations and hating her brother are not on the same level as murder.
|
Haha, you really do grasp at straws to make a point don't you. Cersei murdered a ton of people with no real justification at all other than her own preservation and twisted desires, and had many of them painfully tortured without a second thought, but you try to pull out three examples from her huge list of murders and bad deeds and say they aren't as bad as murder. But even that is a fail.
The false accusations would lead to Margery's death, so it's at least attempted murder. Plus her own incompetence is what mostly keeps it from working when all the people she made participate in it start turning on her (shocking), but Cersei certainly wanted Margery put to death.
Hating her brother is not the same as murder? Really? It would be murder if she had her way. She tried to have the KG kill Tyrion in the Blackwater, but Pod saved him. She bribed witnesses and generally railroaded Tyrion in his trial because it would mean his death. When he gets away, she puts a huge bounty on his head in hoped of having him captured and killed. Tyrion is alive despite Cersei, not because she is not bad or didn;t try her best to kill him.
You clearly don't care about logic in this discussion, so I'm moving on.