Quote:
Originally Posted by O.city
This
Identify your guy an take him. Don't **** around
Curious Dane , who are you leaning toward?
|
I've seen far more of Barkley than I have Geno Smith, so that may be a little unfair, but quite frankly, Smith has been underwhelming to me, especially the past several weeks. His decision making has been suspect and Kansas State shut him down.
I realize that it's unfair to make a judgement at this point on Smith, so I have to give him an Incomplete. But at this point in time,
before Bowl season,
before the Combines,
before we know who will be the GM and head coach of the Chiefs and which offensive system they'll run (although it'll likely be the WCO for either Smith or Barkley), I give the edge to Barkley.
I think that Barkley will be a solid, if not spectacular, NFL QB at
this juncture. Again, that's subject change, especially after the Combine.
Barkley's ceiling may not be as high as Geno's but he can be an immediate starter and difference maker. Geno may get there someday and maybe he won't. He'll need a
ton more coaching, IMO.