Butler is a DH. If I have to trade one, I think I'd go with him. It'd be an unpopular move for sure and he is an excellent hitter. However, the fact that Meyers can play the field and has a potential for a big bat out weighs a big bat that can really only play DH.
That being said to part with Billy it would have to be for a #1 or really darn good #2.
|