Quote:
Originally Posted by Cassel's Reckoning
The debate is who is better as a WR.
Comparing RB receiving yards to WR receiving yards is comparing apples to oranges.
Dex sucks as a WR because he's not very good at beating CBs and is useless going down the field.
He can produce some receiving yards as a RB because he's matched up on linebackers, can catch screens, etc.
That doesn't translate to his play as a WR.
He has about 300 yards as an actual WR, doing WR things, running routes. Period.
End of discussion.
|
Nobody is arguing who the better true WR is! You just now invented that it is all of the sudden a debate about the better WR because you failed at who the better player is. You said Tate > McCluster without the caveat "as a WR."
So I will say again, Calvin Johnson is better than Ray Rice at doing WR things, but Ray Rice is still the better football player that most people would prefer to have.