Quote:
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud
Alex Smith has better numbers yet less talented perimeter players and most definitely a less talented offensive line.
I'd take Wilson due to his age, but as far as this season is concerned, it's splitting hairs, IMO.
|
I'll take Wilson if age wasn't a factor (and it's really not. Wilson will be 25 soon, just 4 years younger than Smith).
Wilson's got a better offensive line, I'll give him that, but his receiving options aren't exactly lightyears ahead of what Smith has. Are Golden Tate, Doug Baldwin, and Ben Obamanu really that much better than Dwayne Bowe, Donnie Avery and Dexter McCluster?
Also can't forget the quality of teams he's taken down. He doesn't do it like Drew Brees yet, but the man has barely played 20 NFL regular season games in his entire career. He'll get there.