Quote:
Originally Posted by Coogs
If you are correct, and it is an either/or situation, then give me Geno. And while I would rather get Alex on the "released from the 49ers route", I would still prefer to have Alex for a 4th, than the 10th or 12th best QB out of the draft class.
I am all for having a legit QB competition. If ran correctly, it won't set the team back... and probablly make the team better. The last four seasons have shown us what happens when someone is handed the keys with no threat to his job.
|
Legit QB competitions don't happen in the NFL when one guy is a proven vet and the other guy is a draft pick.
If you want a legit QB competition, you don't want Alex Smith.
The NFL is conservative by nature. The former starter is ALWAYS going to win an "open competition".