Quote:
Originally Posted by jspchief
OK. What does it take to make the criticisms legitimate?
1. He needs a TE (or two?). How good are we talking?
2. He needs a RT and what else on the Oline? The 49ers built him a pretty damn good line. Is that what it takes?
3. He needs a slot receiver. Again, what caliber?
Do you think when he gets all of those things, he will become a QB capable of spreading a defense? Will he become 300+ yd QB?
|
I think as far as the criticisms go he wants you guys to just stop bitching like 3 year olds about something you can't control.
What he's discussing is how to improve the offense as a whole, and it's all perfectly logical. Interior linemen are very important when you use short drops (look at how the Saints OL is built... great interior) and Alex is going to do a lot of that and he's going to throw short over the middle a lot. He's not exactly explaining rocket science, nor is he telling anyone how Alex is going to become a top 5 QB.
Alex will not be a top 5 QB, but you can win with him and the offense CAN get better with him. Instead it degenerates into bitching about Alex Smith. It's redundant.