Hosmer?
The eye says he hasn't lived up to his MiL defensive reputation. And his UZR is -11.5 -- dead last in the AL. Even allowing for the imprecision of defensive metrics, he can't be one of the top 3 1B. Can he?
And Francoeur? He's got a great arm, but his range has really declined.
Moose and Gordon, obviously. And even though he played only half a season, I really think Sal Perez deserves to be there.