[kcbubb]

Originally Posted by SNR

Kcbubb:

Which of these QBs would you draft at #1 overall without the benefit of hindsight? Strictly by what they did in college:

Newton - he was worth the pick based on God given talent. Huge arm, quick release, 6'6", huge and can run. And a winner. Big competitor. Questionable passer and questionable ability to read defenses. so, yes.

Bradford - very accurate and smart. probably my favorite on this list coming out of college. High ceiling but also the least likely to bust.

Stafford - yes. Big arm. pro style offense. Int troubles but GA throws the ball downfield.

Ryan - no. I thought he was too inconsistent at the time. too many ints.

Russell - yes. big time talent. played well in big games.

Smith (Alex) -No.

....