Quote:
Originally Posted by RunKC
I agree, but saying Geno is gonna be great by what we've seen in college is questionable, though I like his game.
I hate it when people say Geno is going to be better than RG3. RG3 is the real deal in every facet.
Geno has questions that have exposed him in college that RG3 never had (reading defenses).
I would easily take Geno with the 1st pick this year (I would take Tyler Wilson too), but if I had a choice between Geno and RG3 I'm taking RG3 10/10 times without thinking twice.
|
Nobody said Geno would be a better QB.
The post you took umbrage with said that they felt Smith could be better than RG3 at STAYING HEALTHY. And they would be absolutely correct. RG3's longevity is absolutely a concern, as evidenced by the amount of time they spent discussing it in the MNF per-game.
As for the idea that there were no questions about whether or not RG3 could read defenses, that is pure revisionist history. There absolutely were questions about it during his season last year.