|
|
06-29-2005, 07:44 PM
|
|
|
Don't Tease Me
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: KS
Casino cash: $11047037
|
linebacker ratings
2005 player ratings: Linebackers
By Howard Balzer, Sports Weekly http://www.usatoday.com/sports/footb...ebackers_x.htm Linebackers anchor the second part of our 2005 NFL player ratings, developed by The Sports Xchange for Sports Weekly. The Sports Xchange based the ratings on a 100-point scale, incorporating more than 40 categories to grade each player, including importance to the team. The players are sorted into seven categories: Elite, A Notch Below, Rock Solid, Under the Radar, On the Rise, On the Rebound and Setting Sun. Derrick Brooks is no spring chicken, but still rates as Sports Weekly's top outside LB. Only Ray Lewis graded ahead of Brooks when ranking all LBs. By Barbara Jean Germano, Sports Weekly OUTSIDE LINEBACKERS Elite The best the NFL has to offer are clearly bunched together. The elder statesman of the group, Tampa Bay's Derrick Brooks, remains the cream of the crop. Perhaps he's slipping slightly as any 32-year-old might, but he is still perched at the top until someone knocks him off. Tennessee's Keith Bulluck and Atlanta's Keith Brooking could be close to doing just that. Brooking has found a home on the outside, but he has the versatility to play in the middle. Bulluck has ascended to an elite status, but he has a lot of changing parts around him as the Titans rework their roster. Joey Porter of the Steelers had only seven sacks last season playing outside in the team's 3-4 defense, so it's questionable how much longer his elite status will last. Buffalo's Takeo Spikes is just behind Porter, but his all-around play could move him up this list in 2006. A notch below Willie McGinest and Mike Vrabel are two of many players who make New England's defense operate. McGinest sometimes lines up as a defensive end, while Vrabel can be found just about anywhere. McGinest, 33, shows no signs of letting up. Marcus Washington made a large impact on the Redskins' No. 3-rated defense, and he played better than expected after leaving the Colts as an unrestricted free agent. Rock solid Dexter Coakley began losing playing time in Dallas last season, then was released early in the offseason as the Cowboys contemplated moving to a 3-4 defense. He was quickly signed by the Rams, who believe his experience and tackling ability will help a defense that finished 29th against the run. Ian Gold spent a year away from Denver with the Buccaneers, proving he could recover from a 2003 knee injury. His speed was still evident, and when Tampa Bay elected not to pay him a large option bonus, Gold landed back with the Broncos. He helps give Denver one of the fastest linebacking corps in the NFL. When Steve Foley left Houston for San Diego as an unrestricted free agent in March 2004, it was not a move that generated headlines. Finding a perfect fit with San Diego's 3-4 defense, Foley had 10 sacks and will now try to prove his breakout season wasn't a fluke. Cincinnati's Brian Simmons consistently plays at a high level, but the Bengals' overall defense has not. With improvement from the entire unit, Simmons could receive more notice. David Thornton of Indianapolis stepped up after the departure of Washington last season and played well. The 26-year-old should get better. Like Foley, when the Jets signed Eric Barton from Oakland in early March, it hardly caused a ripple. But Barton was a large part of a defensive rise that saw the Jets rank seventh overall and fifth against the run. On the rise D.J. Williams is the other outside speedster on Denver's defense, and he needed little learning time after being selected 17th overall in 2004. The Broncos ranked fourth in the league in total defense, fourth against the run, and Williams' play as a rookie was a big reason for that success. Pittsburgh's Clark Haggans has the ability to make plays in his team's 3-4 defense. He had six sacks last season, and as he gets more experience those numbers could increase. With the Ravens switching back to a 4-3 defense, Adalius Thomas has the chance to become a tackling machine playing next to Ray Lewis. Baltimore will need that for its defense to remain elite. Chicago's Lance Briggs kept the team's defense from collapsing when Brian Urlacher missed several games because of injuries. Teamed with a healthy Urlacher, Chicago's defense should rise on the charts. Youth will have a chance to shine with Carolina's Will Witherspoon, Philadelphia's Dhani Jones and Arizona's Karlos Dansby. Witherspoon is on the verge of great things, while Jones began to establish himself after signing with the Eagles as a free agent in 2004. Dansby, a second-round pick last season, is expected to help the Cardinals' defense rise after a surprising No. 12 ranking last season. On the rebound San Francisco's Julian Peterson could be an elite player, but he has to show it this season in his comeback from an Achilles' tendon injury. A healthy Peterson should be able to put up monster numbers with the 49ers switching to a 3-4 defense. Lavar Arrington of the Redskins is coming back from a knee injury that made his 2004 season one to forget. Without him, the Redskins were one of the top defenses in the league. With him, they could be better. Setting sun If Chad Brown is nearing the end of the line, what better place to have it happen than New England? He still has the ability to make plays, but injuries have been his biggest problem in recent seasons. Injuries have also robbed Anthony Simmons of his excellence, and after being released by the Seahawks this offseason, he remains unsigned. The sun might truly set on his career this year. INSIDE LINEBACKERS Elite Ray Lewis has set the standard for middle linebacker play. He is 30 now, but the feeling is that his production will rise with the Ravens moving back to a 4-3 defense that should free him to make more plays. Establishing the order for the next four players after Lewis wasn't easy, but they are almost interchangeable. Chicago's Brian Urlacher might be the second best of the group, but the injuries he suffered last season drop him a notch. Pittsburgh's James Farrior has found a home on the inside of the team's 3-4 defense after failing to live up to expectations with the Jets. Al Wilson of the Broncos is the heart of Denver's outstanding linebacker corps. Kansas City coach Dick Vermeil still can't believe he let Donnie Edwards go in 2002. Edwards has become the leader of a Chargers defense that should be better in the second year of coordinator Wade Phillips' 3-4 defense. A notch below Miami's Zach Thomas has defied the experts ever since entering the league as a fifth-round draft pick in 1996. He might not be an elite middle linebacker, but a lot of teams would love to have him manning their middle. Dan Morgan of Carolina could be on the verge of elite status, especially if he can avoid the concussions that have haunted him since being the 11th overall pick in the 2001 draft. Carolina's defensive line is outstanding, but the defense is much better when Morgan is healthy. Philadelphia's Jeremiah Trotter is a difficult player to rate. Often undisciplined, he was released by the Redskins in June 2004 and returned to Philadelphia, where his career began. He didn't even start until the second half of last season.When he did, Trotter was the player coaches have been waiting for. The Bills put together a defense that ranked second in 2004, and London Fletcher is the emotional leader. He excels with smarts and the ability to get to the ball. So what if he's only 5-10? His lack of height for a linebacker has never affected his play. Ed Hartwell will answer a lot of questions in Atlanta this season after signing as an unrestricted free agent. Is he a player a defense can be built around, or was his play in Baltimore due as much to the great players around him? The Falcons are banking on the former. Rock solid The Colts' loss was the Jaguars' gain in 2003 when Indianapolis couldn't afford to retain Mike Peterson. He is not an elite player, but his tackling ability helps give the Jaguars one of the better run defenses in the league. No one expected Dat Nguyen to last when Bill Parcells took over as Dallas' coach because he didn't fit the Parcells profile of big linebackers. But Nguyen has a nose for the ball, and when he tackles, no one notices he's only 5-11. He might be even more effective in the Cowboys' 3-4 defense. Kailee Wong moves to the inside of Houston's defense, where he is expected to call the plays in the huddle. Chris Claiborne has spent his career moving between the outside and inside, which has led to the label of being an underachiever after being picked ninth overall in 1999. But in St. Louis he will man the middle, the position he prefers. This will be his opportunity to answer those who say he hasn't lived up to expectations. As the 49ers plummeted to the bottom of the NFL, Derek Smith's play has largely gone unnoticed. But it shouldn't. He adeptly takes on blockers, and he might now be more effective in San Francisco's 3-4 defense. On the rise Antonio Pierce's strong play in Washington last season came at the right time. With his contract expiring, he was able to command a large deal from the Giants, who expect him to be part of a rejuvenated run defense. The Jets, meanwhile, got from rookie Jonathan Vilma what the Giants hope to get from Pierce. Vilma was the perfect fit for new coordinator Donnie Henderson's defense, and he certainly lived up to being the 12th pick in the draft last year as the consensus choice as Defensive Rookie of the Year. Andra Davis might not be a household name, but he will be once new coach Romeo Crennel is able to put his stamp on the Browns' defense. Davis is strong and smart, and one of the better tacklers in the league. This could be a crossroads year for Green Bay's Nick Barnett. He was better as a rookie than he was last season, but some of that could be due to the change in defensive coordinators. The coordinator has changed again, and Barnett will have to adapt to Jim Bates' system. Pittsburgh's Larry Foote is a player to watch in 2005. He filled in for the injured Kendrell Bell last season, and with Bell gone to Kansas City, the job is his. Foote was signed to a long-term contract to keep from being an unrestricted free agent next March. On the rebound Kendrell Bell moved to the Chiefs from the Steelers after a groin injury limited him to only three games in 2004. The Chiefs are hoping he can stay healthy and help a defense that ranked next to last in the league last season. Healthy, New England's Tedy Bruschi is an elite player with incredible big-play ability. But his status remains in doubt following a stroke he suffered in February. Should he come back and play this season, his will be one of the most-followed stories in the NFL. Setting sun New England's Ted Johnson might not have a whole lot of time left, but he remains a stalwart in the Patriots' defense. He's 32, but he can make plays thanks to experience and smarts. Jamie Sharper was released by Houston, and Seattle hopes that at 30 he has at least two seasons of solid play left. Tampa Bay's Shelton Quarles has always been underrated, but now he's 33 and will be challenged by rookie Barrett Ruud. |
|
Posts: 95,626
  |
|
|
06-29-2005, 07:55 PM
|
#2 |
|
In BB I trust
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Boston, Mass.
Casino cash: $10029808
|
McGinest and Vrabel both in the top 10 as outside 'backers is unusually perceptive. While one can quibble with their exact rankings, usually one or the other is ranked waaay too low. Both are easily top 15, IMHO, and 7 and 9 seems about right.
__________________
"I love signature blocks on the Internet. I get to put whatever the hell I want in quotes, pick a pretend author, and bang, it's like he really said it." George Washington |
|
Posts: 43,125
|
|
|
06-29-2005, 08:19 PM
|
#4 | |||
|
How tall is this thing?
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Ground 0 for enema of US.
Casino cash: $2012912
|
Quote:
Heh. Not quite. Apparently these sportswriters are going by the previous position that Bell played, and not his new one in KC. Last I heard, Bell was going to be outside and that Mitchell was the leading candidate for the middle spot. Id feel a lot better if Bell were on the inside, but Gun has been preaching about wanting his presence on the outside since he was signed.
__________________
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
|
Posts: 7,928
|
|
|
06-29-2005, 08:24 PM
|
#5 | |
|
Dumbass!
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Leading the Marty bashing
Casino cash: $10029395
|
Quote:
Using his position in the past makes it appear that they don't have any clue, which of course, they don't.
__________________
|
|
|
Posts: 70,769
|
|
|
06-29-2005, 10:08 PM
|
#10 |
|
Busy in a Kohl's restroom
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Milk/Honey/Gazland
Casino cash: $1747293
|
Here's to Bell & D.J. being on the list next year!
__________________
You seem nice! |
|
Posts: 22,376
|
|
|
06-30-2005, 12:39 PM
|
#11 | |
|
Don't Tease Me
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: KS
Casino cash: $11047037
|
Quote:
how are they supposed to judge them on a position they are going to play this year, when they have played it yet? that makes no sense this was a article about rating the performance of linebackers, not predicting it.
__________________
|
|
|
Posts: 95,626
|
|
|
|
|
Linear Mode
