Ely Manning

[MTG#10]

Is a ****in' stud. Along with everyone else I thought for sure San Diego got the best end of that deal but now its obvious the Giants did.

[kstater]

Ely May of the Beverly Hillbillies was hot.

[Mecca]

Well his WR made a tremendous catch for him too....

[Ultra Peanut]

IT'S A TOOMAH

[Basileus777]

The Giants got the best of the draft because they won a Superbowl. But its debatable whether Rivers or Eli is better. But Eli is certainly not better than Rivers + Merriman + Kaeding.

Either way, Roethlisberger is still the best qb in that draft.

[dj56dt58]

Originally Posted by Basileus777

The Giants got the best of the draft because they won a Superbowl. But its debatable whether Rivers or Eli is better. But Eli is certainly not better than Rivers + Merriman + Kaeding.

Either way, Roethlisberger is still the best qb in that draft.

Seriously? He's a good qb, great at managing the game..but he's not gonna put his team on his back every Sunday like Eli can

[Basileus777]

Originally Posted by dj56dt58

Seriously? He's a good qb, great at managing the game..but he's not gonna put his team on his back every Sunday like Eli can

Eli doesn't put his team on his back every Sunday. I have seen every pro game Eli has ever played. Eli has never been asked to carry the Giants. They have won with their defense and rushing attack. Eli is great in no huddle and clutch situations, but he's wildly inconsistent throughout the rest of the game.

I'll take Eli if I need a game winning TD, but I'll take Ben the rest of the game.

[MichaelH]

He should do something about his swollen tongue.

[KCwolf]

I thought Ely had a swollen vagina......

[dj56dt58]

Originally Posted by Basileus777

Eli doesn't put his team on his back every Sunday. I have seen every pro game Eli has ever played. Eli has never been asked to carry the Giants. They have won with their defense and rushing attack. Eli is great in no huddle and clutch situations, but he's wildly inconsistent throughout the rest of the game.

I'll take Eli if I need a game winning TD, but I'll take Ben the rest of the game.

ok..well turn the Steelers game on and tell me if you would take Ben this game..

[Basileus777]

Originally Posted by dj56dt58

ok..well turn the Steelers game on and tell me if you would take Ben this game..

If Eli was under this kind of pressure he would have thrown 4 picks. Eli has had one of the best olines in the league his entire career, but when he's been under alot of pressure, he hasn't played well, just like any other qb.

[Brock]

Phillip Rivers is just as good, if not better.

[JuicesFlowing]

He's turned out to be a solid QB .. Even when he was struggling, he was better than the Chiefs young QB's ... but we'll see in 10 weeks when Croyle finally is healthy.

[Bearcat]

Originally Posted by JuicesFlowing

He's turned out to be a solid QB .. Even when he was struggling, he was better than the Chiefs young QB's ... but we'll see in 10 weeks when Croyle finally is healthy.

What's funny about Eli is that he did less with more talent for 4 years, and now that he has a ring, people think he's worth the pick, money, and hype. Croyle has similar stats (through the first handful of starts) with less talent around him, and the majority of Chiefs have thrown him under the bus (which isn't good since he's so fragile).

Originally Posted by JuicesFlowing

PS I thought his name was ELI?

Yeah, that one was new to me.

[JuicesFlowing]

Originally Posted by Bearcat

What's funny about Eli is that he did less with more talent for 4 years, and now that he has a ring, people think he's worth the pick, money, and hype. Croyle has similar stats.

I won't throw Croyle under the bus with our O-line ... the thing is, he might not ever get a chance to prove himself behind a good line. I basically give LJ the same credit ... it's amazing LJ ran for over 100 yrds today ... it's all about the line.