Tim Tebow is John Elway

[WhiteWhale]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

Elway's annual rank in QB rating over the course of his career.

1983 - 27th
1984 - 17th
1985 - 17th
1986 - 11th
1987 - 12th
1988 - 18th
1989 - 17th
1990 - 14th
1991 - 19th
1992 - 20th
1993 - 3rd
1994 - 4th
1995 - 14th
1996 - 4th
1997 - 7th
1998 - 5th

Granted, from 1993 on he was productive, once new coaches arrived on the scene who recognized that he was more of a complementary player than a star to build around. Once they shifted the focus to other, better players, Elway did fine as a second banana type of quarterback.

You sure do think QB rating is the most important thing ever don't you?

So by your logic Cassel > Elway.

Solid logic. Not flawed at all.

I hate elway more than any player ever, and it's not because he was an average QB. I can't believe anyone could watch him play and say this nonsense. Elway could do things on a football field that nobody has done before or since.