Misc A complaint about quotation marks

**RealSNR** · 06-30-2009, 12:10 AM

I have a complaint.

When you want to write out a question and your sentence contains a set of quotation marks at the end, it's the rule to write it out like this:

Did you know John Adams died shortly after uttering his last words, "Thomas Jefferson survives?"

But what about a sentence like this?

Did you know Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?"

Now in the first sentence, the question mark ends the entire sentence, which is a question. So shouldn't it make sense that the question mark should go AFTER the quotation marks? Putting it inside seems to suggest that it is a question being asked by someone in the sentence, which is not true. In the second sentence, it's okay, because the overall sentence at the question itself require a question mark. But now, what if we turn the 2nd sentence into a statement?

Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?"

The sentence is not a question, but a statement. If we REALLY wanted to be thorough, we should put a period at the end of the quotation marks. Then it would also follow that we could write the second sentence like this: Did you know Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?"? It's less efficient, but it's practical. There's a mark at the end of the sentence in the quotation marks, and there's a punctuation mark at the end of the sentence. They're two different things, and the quotations should not get in the way presenting the reader with this information.

Basically, my point is I don't see any reason why punctuation is not allowed to go outside quotation marks. Why? Because it's more aesthetically pleasing the other way? That's stupid. Language should have rules that are practical and make sense.

Who's with me on this?

06-30-2009, 12:10 AM	Topic Starter
RealSNR Special Teams ACE!!! Join Date: Apr 2002 Location: Where the hell is SNR Casino cash: $-1484792	A complaint about quotation marks I have a complaint. When you want to write out a question and your sentence contains a set of quotation marks at the end, it's the rule to write it out like this: Did you know John Adams died shortly after uttering his last words, "Thomas Jefferson survives?" But what about a sentence like this? Did you know Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?" Now in the first sentence, the question mark ends the entire sentence, which is a question. So shouldn't it make sense that the question mark should go AFTER the quotation marks? Putting it inside seems to suggest that it is a question being asked by someone in the sentence, which is not true. In the second sentence, it's okay, because the overall sentence at the question itself require a question mark. But now, what if we turn the 2nd sentence into a statement? Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?" The sentence is not a question, but a statement. If we REALLY wanted to be thorough, we should put a period at the end of the quotation marks. Then it would also follow that we could write the second sentence like this: Did you know Billy Butthead died shortly after asking his wife, "Did you gain weight?"? It's less efficient, but it's practical. There's a mark at the end of the sentence in the quotation marks, and there's a punctuation mark at the end of the sentence. They're two different things, and the quotations should not get in the way presenting the reader with this information. Basically, my point is I don't see any reason why punctuation is not allowed to go outside quotation marks. Why? Because it's more aesthetically pleasing the other way? That's stupid. Language should have rules that are practical and make sense. Who's with me on this?
Posts: 93,408