Would you pay a 2nd for Steve Smith, WR NYG?

[DJ's left nut]

Originally Posted by buddha

Whether you like Cassel or not, he went to the Pro Bowl after last season. He was much better than most of the sad sacks on this board predicted. McCluster got hurt, but was the talk of the league before that happened. He was a strong pick where we got him...a difference maker. And what's your bitch with Arenas? He wasn't good enough on returns for you? He worked his way into the defensive backfield as well later in the season and played well.

What the hell?

Bono made a Pro Bowl. Grbac made a Pro Bowl. I don't give a shit if Matt Cassel made a Pro Bowl - he still sucks.

McCluster was the talk of the league? WTF are you talking about? He was talked about for 1 week after he returned a punt against one of the worst special teams units in NFL history. From there he was irrelevant and now he's a 3rd down back. Awesome pick.

Arenas was an incredibly mediocre punt returner and nothing more than Benny Sapp or Maurice Leggett as a defensive back.

If we could get Steve Smith, a 26 year old player who put up 100+ catches and 1,200 yards in his second season in the league, instead of any of those guys, we'd be far better for it.