Kurt Warner Comeback???

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by tk13

I never said "anti-correlated," I said it was overrated. Don't twist my words. Even for a lot of those guys you listed, their overall performance wasn't their career best the year they won. Football is a funny game.

Plus defense is way more important than this place will ever give it credit for.

Russell Wilson stretches the field more than Alex Smith.

Alex Smith stretches the field less than every other QB in the league. Literally.

You cannot win with a guy like that.

So it's not just the lack of yardage. It's that Alex is consistently at the bottom in:

YPG
YPA
YPC
TD

That is not a recipe for success.