Quarterbackery: Round 4, Heat 6

[Al Bundy]

The only reason I didn't vote Tampa last was because Winston is already better than any QB the Bears have had in the last 50 years.

[Rain Man]

Originally Posted by Al Bundy

The only reason I didn't vote Tampa last was because Winston is already better than any QB the Bears have had in the last 50 years.

It was probably a mistake on their part to trade Steve Young.

[Al Bundy]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

It was probably a mistake on their part to trade Steve Young.

That was Ray Perkins.. he was a ****stick and is the worst head coach in the history of the Buccaneers.

[Rain Man]

Originally Posted by Al Bundy

That was Ray Perkins.. he was a ****stick and is the worst head coach in the history of the Buccaneers.

How would you rank the TB quarterbacks? In fairness, Young was pretty raw with the Bucs, but it still hurts.

I haven't seen Winston, so I'll hold him out, but I would probably rank the top three as:

Brad Johnson
Steve Deberg
Vinny Testaverde

Maybe Doug Williams was better, or Josh Freeman. I was surprised at Josh Freeman's fast departure and Mike Glennon's fast fall, because they seemed to have potential based on what I saw in highlights and the occasional game.

[Al Bundy]

Originally Posted by Rain Man

How would you rank the TB quarterbacks? In fairness, Young was pretty raw with the Bucs, but it still hurts.

I haven't seen Winston, so I'll hold him out, but I would probably rank the top three as:

Brad Johnson
Steve Deberg
Vinny Testaverde

Maybe Doug Williams was better, or Josh Freeman. I was surprised at Josh Freeman's fast departure and Mike Glennon's fast fall, because they seemed to have potential based on what I saw in highlights and the occasional game.

I would rank them in this order
Brad Johnson
Jameis Winston
Doug Williams
Vinny Testaverde
Steve Deberg
Josh Freeman
Steve Young (he wasn't good with the Bucs, but I blame that on Leeman Bennett being clueless)
Trent Dilfer
Mike Glennon
Craig Erickson
the rest is complete crap.

[Rain Man]

Originally Posted by Al Bundy

I would rank them in this order
Brad Johnson
Jameis Winston
Doug Williams
Vinny Testaverde
Steve Deberg
Josh Freeman
Steve Young (he wasn't good with the Bucs, but I blame that on Leeman Bennett being clueless)
Trent Dilfer
Mike Glennon
Craig Erickson
the rest is complete crap.

Admittedly, I don't remember the differences between the Williams and Testaverde eras.

I liked Brad Johnson for both the Buccaneers and Vikings. But overall, it appears that we agree that it's a cringeworthy list. (And yet the Buccaneers have a Super Bowl win in the last 15 years. Sigh.)