So...um...Mahomes lost us this game

[comochiefsfan]

The eye test is beginning to heavily favor Allen.

Much higher degree of difficulty on touchdown passes.

Downfield lasers into tight windows.

Superior athleticism and rushing ability

And recently, better performance in the clutch.

If you ask me who I'm taking today, it would be REALLY hard to not objectively say Josh Allen.

[louie aguiar]

Originally Posted by comochiefsfan

The eye test is beginning to heavily favor Allen.

Much higher degree of difficulty on touchdown passes.

Downfield lasers into tight windows.

Superior athleticism and rushing ability

And recently, better performance in the clutch.

If you ask me who I'm taking today, it would be REALLY hard to not objectively say Josh Allen.

I know you’ll get crucified for this comment but it’s a lot closer than I ever thought it would be and many if not most objective football fans would agree with you.

[Gary Cooper]

Originally Posted by comochiefsfan

The eye test is beginning to heavily favor Allen.

Much higher degree of difficulty on touchdown passes.

Downfield lasers into tight windows.

Superior athleticism and rushing ability

And recently, better performance in the clutch.

If you ask me who I'm taking today, it would be REALLY hard to not objectively say Josh Allen.

Oh please. Allen had a clean pocket all day and a good run game for support. Plus he has more weapons at receiver. Of course he would look better to an untrained eye.

Here's the real test. If the two QB's switched places yesterday, which team wins and by how much?

[DRM08]

Originally Posted by JudasRising20

Oh please. Allen had a clean pocket all day and a good run game for support. Plus he has more weapons at receiver. Of course he would look better to an untrained eye.

Here's the real test. If the two QB's switched places yesterday, which team wins and by how much?

In the Buffalo & KC games, I think Mahomes has had the tougher job going against Buffalo's defense instead of KC's defense. We keep hearing about how Buffalo has the best defense in the league, so I think they should get some credit for making it tough on him. But he needs to be a lot more careful with the ball. He has also been pretty bad at the end of games recently, which isn't a good trend.

Bengals game: terrible 2nd half
Chargers game: not good, bailed out by 99 yard Pick 6 on Herbert
Colts game: not good, INT at very end
Tampa game: good for 3 quarters, bad INT late in game
Raiders game: blew it on 3rd and 3, bailed out by Raiders final drive
Buffalo game: Obviously 2 bad INT's in critical situations

[JPH83]

Originally Posted by JudasRising20

Oh please. Allen had a clean pocket all day and a good run game for support. Plus he has more weapons at receiver. Of course he would look better to an untrained eye.

Here's the real test. If the two QB's switched places yesterday, which team wins and by how much?

That Buffalo OL isn't that good, largely Allen has worked around it because he's ridiculously mobile. That said his LT IS playing much better than ours, he has better WRs and he isn't being chased by Von Miller.

Allen's probably playing slightly better right now, but if I picture him protected by Brown and Wylie and throwing to MVS and JJSS, I don't see him out-performing Mahomes.

[kcbubb]

Agreed. Allen has a better supporting cast offensively and a better defense.

Originally Posted by JudasRising20

Oh please. Allen had a clean pocket all day and a good run game for support. Plus he has more weapons at receiver. Of course he would look better to an untrained eye.

Here's the real test. If the two QB's switched places yesterday, which team wins and by how much?