Ely Manning

[Basileus777]

Originally Posted by dj56dt58

Seriously? He's a good qb, great at managing the game..but he's not gonna put his team on his back every Sunday like Eli can

Eli doesn't put his team on his back every Sunday. I have seen every pro game Eli has ever played. Eli has never been asked to carry the Giants. They have won with their defense and rushing attack. Eli is great in no huddle and clutch situations, but he's wildly inconsistent throughout the rest of the game.

I'll take Eli if I need a game winning TD, but I'll take Ben the rest of the game.