Oregon was jobbed

[Cave Johnson]

Let me preface this by saying I didn't watch the game, because the BCS can eat a bag of dicks. I don't know whether Auburn would have scored anyway, or won in OT. But to have this kind of inconsistent officiating, in a game played 5 weeks after the season is over, is disgraceful.

[jd1020]

This is beyond stupid. His hand was flat, palm down. In the first instance the runners hand that was around the ball hit the ground, palm up.

[Saulbadguy]

I saw no flags for excessive celebration either - although I did not watch the entire game.

[baitism]

The call was right. Stop whining. I was rooting for Oregon, too.

[Bane]

Yeah ok,but Oregon ****ed themselves by turning the ball over instead of scoring TD's.

[Frosty]

I didn't see that you started a thread about it. Here is what I wrote in the other thread.

I guess you would have to define exactly where the wrist is. In the Ark example, it was the back of the hand/ wrist that was down. In the Auburn example, it was the palm that was down and could be considered just the hand. With the palm down, it's hard to have the wrist down, too, without having the forearm come down unless the hand is rocked back, which it wasn't.


BTW, I'm not sure the safety wasn't a worse call as it seemed like James got the ball out at the last second. However, Oregon lined up off-sides all night long and it was never called, so screw 'em.

[Cave Johnson]

Originally Posted by jd1020

This is beyond stupid. His hand was flat, palm down. In the first instance the runners hand that was around the ball hit the ground, palm up.

The rulebook doesn't specify that it has to be the hand with the ball to be down. Nor does it distinguish flat hand from curled.

[Pestilence]

Let me preface this by saying I didn't watch the game

Then .

[jd1020]

Originally Posted by Frosty

BTW, I'm not sure the safety wasn't a worse call as it seemed like James got the ball out at the last second. However, Oregon lined up off-sides all night long and it was never called, so screw 'em.

The ball was half on the line. How is that out of the endzone?

[baitism]

Originally Posted by Frosty

BTW, I'm not sure the safety wasn't a worse call as it seemed like James got the ball out at the last second. However, Oregon lined up off-sides all night long and it was never called, so screw 'em.

That call was right, too. The WHOLE ball has to get past the goal line, not just the tip, and it clearly did not.

[jd1020]

Originally Posted by Pittsie

The rulebook doesn't specify that it has to be the hand with the ball to be down. Nor does it distinguish flat hand from curled.

Brace yourself up with your palm down and tell me if your wrist is touching the ground. Then roll over with your palm up, holding a football, and tell me if your wrist hits the ground.

[ChiTown]

Originally Posted by Frosty

I didn't see that you started a thread about it. Here is what I wrote in the other thread.

I guess you would have to define exactly where the wrist is. In the Ark example, it was the back of the hand/ wrist that was down. In the Auburn example, it was the palm that was down and could be considered just the hand. With the palm down, it's hard to have the wrist down, too, without having the forearm come down unless the hand is rocked back, which it wasn't.


BTW, I'm not sure the safety wasn't a worse call as it seemed like James got the ball out at the last second. However, Oregon lined up off-sides all night long and it was never called, so screw 'em.

The ball has to be ENTIRELY over the endzone line - not just part of the ball. That was an easy call.

[Frosty]

Originally Posted by ChiTown

The ball has to be ENTIRELY over the endzone line - not just part of the ball. That was an easy call.

My bad. I thought it just had to break the plane, like a touchdown.

[kstater]

Originally Posted by Saulbadguy

I saw no flags for excessive celebration either - although I did not watch the entire game.

I saw several players drawing attention to themselves last night.

[baitism]

I thought the game was officiated very well, unlike years back when the refs gifted Ohio State a national championship with a blatantly late and terrible PI call.