Mark Ingram or Toby Gerhart?

[rico]

I have both of these guys at RB, but am unsure who to start.

I know Mark Ingram is projected to be used in goal line situations. But I recently heard that Gerhart will be the featured back this weekend due to them proceeding cautiously with AP's ACL. I know close to nothing about Gerhart, other than he was a 2nd or 3rd round pick a couple years ago. Does he have skills? Do I start him over Ingram?

[Direckshun]

I like Gerhart more, if I had to choose. We still don't know Ingram's role in the Saints offense, and they are not going to rush AP back.

Gerhart is a decent runner, but he's good enough in the passing game that they give him 90% of the snaps. He's also a solid goalline back while AP is out.

[rico]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

I like Gerhart more, if I had to choose. We still don't know Ingram's role in the Saints offense, and they are not going to rush AP back.

Gerhart is a decent runner, but he's good enough in the passing game that they give him 90% of the snaps. He's also a solid goalline back while AP is out.

Thank you, Sir.