Rank the Chiefs top ten players

[CBob]

What do you reckon? Who are the Chiefs ten best players and can they be put in order?

[Redrum_69]

Your moms mom

[jiveturkey]

Larry Johnson
Tony Gonzales
Brian Waters
Jared Allen
Ty Law
Derrick Johnson
Will Shields
Patrick Surtain
Tamba Hali
Eddie Kennison

[CoMoChief]

You sure can tell which threads are started from n00bs, but here's mine.

1. LJ
2. TonyG
3. Brian Waters
4. Will Shields
5. Jared Allen
6. Derrick Johnson
7. Ty Law
8. Tamba Hali
9. Damon Huard
10. Eddie Kennison

[crazycoffey]

Huard?

[Rooster]

Huard?

Huard would be slots 1 through 3.

[jiveturkey]

Huard?He's played half of a year.

[Archie Bunker]

1. LJ
2. Gonzo
3. Allen
4. Waters
5. Edwards
6. Hali
7. Law
8. DJ
9. Page
10. Colquitt

[Chiefnj]

1. TG
2. Jared Allen
3. LJ
4. Waters

After that it is pretty muddy. Law, Surtain, Hali, DJ, Weigman and maybe Page.

[Micjones]

Larry Johnson
Tony Gonzalez
Brian Waters
Will Shields
Derrick Johnson
Tamba Hali
Jared Allen
Eddie Kennison
Dustin Colquitt
Casey Wiegmann

Can't believe I omitted Allen's name.

[CoMoChief]

Larry Johnson
Tony Gonzalez
Brian Waters
Will Shields
Derrick Johnson
Tamba Hali
Dante Hall
Eddie Kennison
Dustin Colquitt
Casey Wiegmann

Dante Hall are you serious? Casey also played like shit this season.

[Brock]

Larry Johnson
Tony Gonzalez
Brian Waters
Will Shields
Derrick Johnson
Tamba Hali
Dante Hall
Eddie Kennison
Dustin Colquitt
Casey Wiegmann

Uh, Allen, Page?

[StcChief]

LJ
Gonzo
Allen
Waters
DJ
Kennison
Colquitt
Hali
Wiegmann
Law
Pollard
Huard

[The Bad Guy]

LJ
TG
Waters
Allen
Law
DJ
Hali
Shields
Donnie Edwards
Surtain

[crazycoffey]

Huard
Bartee
bell
sims
Dee Brown
Sammy Parker
Nick Reid
keith willis
Derrick Ross
Timi Wusu

[Logical]

You sure can tell which threads are started from n00bs, but here's mine.

1. LJ
2. TonyG
3. Brian Waters
4. Will Shields
5. Jared Allen
6. Derrick Johnson
7. Ty Law
8. Tamba Hali
9. Damon Huard
10. Eddie KennisonNot a bad list except I would not put Damon Huard in any top 10. Probably substitute Casey Wiegman for him.

[ct]

LJ
Waters
Gonzo
DJ
Allen
Surtain
Weigman
Pollard
Shields
Hali

[keg in kc]

Allen
Colquitt
Dunn
Gonzo
Hali
Harris
DJ
LJ
Kennison
Waters

[kc-nd]

How long before someone includes Scanlon on a list?

[keg in kc]

I considered Scanlon, but decided to be serious.

[dj56dt58]

How long before someone includes Scanlon on a list?
Scanlon is above the top 10

[Crush]

I say we trade Scanlon to Detroit for their first round pick.

[Brock]

I say we trade Scanlon to Detroit for their first round pick.

Scanlon has veto power.

[Wile_E_Coyote]

If Ty Law is one of the Chief's 10 best, this team must suck

[Redrum_69]

Trent Green retired, it was just announced

[Archie Bunker]

If Ty Law is one of the Chief's 10 best, this team must suck

Why? Outside of the slipping I thought he had a good year. His playoff performance showed he is still a primetime CB IMO.

[InChiefsHeaven]

Trent Green retired, it was just announced

You're such a wanker...

[RedThat]

Im gonna go by last years season.

10 best players for the Chiefs last season:

-Larry Johnson
-Damon Huard
-Tony Gonzalez
-Jared Allen
-Tamba Hali
-Patrick Surtain
-Ty Law
-Bernard Pollard
-Dustin Colquitt
-Brian Waters

[Wile_E_Coyote]

Why? Outside of the slipping I thought he had a good year. His playoff performance showed he is still a primetime CB IMO.
Two gift wrapped INTs to end the season. Law can still play, but I doubt he is feared by QBs or Wrs anymore. Perhaps "10 best" is to vague. I saw it as 10 hardest to replace with an equal player.

Sadly Will Shields does not belong either. I really didn't want to type that :(

[kc rush]

1. TG
2. LJ
3. Waters
4. Allen
5. DJ
6. Hali
7. D Edwards
8. Surtain
9. Kennison
10. Law

Honorable mentions to Page, Pollard, and Colquitt. They are still young and a bit inconsistent, but could easily move into the top 10 this year.

[CoMoChief]

Not a bad list except I would not put Damon Huard in any top 10. Probably substitute Casey Wiegman for him.


I did simply because without what he did last season we wouldnt have made the playoffs.

[BWillie]

Why are so many people NOT putting Pat Surtain in the top 10, or Law ahead of Surtain. Surtain is the best CB we've had for like five years, which doesn't say much, but he's a hell of a player. Don't let stats sway you, he forces QB's to pick on Law and the donk pickup who I refuse to use by his name.

Gonzo
LJ
Waters
Surtain
DJ
Allen

then the rest.

[Hootie]

1. Jared Allen
2. Tony Gonzalez
3. Larry Johnson
4. Derrick Johnson
5. Brian Waters
6. Ty Law
7. Eddie Kennison
8. Patrick Surtain
9. Tamba Hali
10. Bernard Pollard (Can we really overlook his special teams play last year?)

[keg in kc]

10. Bernard Pollard (Can we really overlook his special teams play last year?)Valid point.

[HolmeZz]

LJ
Allen
Gonzo
Waters
DJ
Hali
Law
Surtain
Kennison
Page

[TinyEvel]

Rank the ChiefsPlanet's top ten REPOSTS

Where's the best Barbecue?
Top ten Chiefs PLayers
Top Ten Worst Players
Where's the best strip club in town?
Should I get DIRECTV or DISH?
Should I get XBOX or PS2(3)
Link to Paris Hilton Sex Vid
Link to kid lighting fireworks out of butt
We might be getting Ty Law
Trent or Huard?

[JBucc]

Here's my rough list that I put little effort into.
1. LJ
2. TG
3. Allen
4. Waters
5. Hali
6. DJ
7. Kennison
8. Law
9. Donnie Edwards
10. Surtain

[ArrowheadHawk]

1 LJ
2 TG
3 Allen
4 DJ
5 Ty Law

not too sure on the other 5

[Phobia]

Larry Johnson
Tony Gonzalez
Brian Waters
Will Shields
Derrick Johnson
Tamba Hali
Jared Allen
Eddie Kennison
Dustin Colquitt
Casey Wiegmann

Can't believe I omitted Allen's name.

I can. He's a white guy.

[Phobia]

I can't possibly rank the Chiefs top ten players because they all play different positions. It's like ranking Lawrence Taylor against Joe Montana. Who was better?

[Extra Point]

Otis Taylor
Len Dawson
Mike Garrett
Buck Buchanan
Willie Lanier
Bobby Bell
Jim Tyrer
Fred Arbanas
Jan Stenerud
Marcus Allen

[beer bacon]

LJ
Gonzo
Waters
Allen
Hali
DJ
DE
Law
Surtain
Kennison

[JBucc]

I can't possibly rank the Chiefs top ten players because they all play different positions. It's like ranking Lawrence Taylor against Joe Montana. Who was better?I'd go with LT

[Crashride]

Scanlon 1-10

[CoMoChief]

I changed my mind......here are mine.

Bartee
Bell
Sims
Hicks
Parker
D. Hall
Black
Bober
Sampson
Wesley

[zeus75]

LJ
GONZO
WATERS
COLQUITT
KENNISON
LAW
SHIELDS
EDWARDS
ALLEN
DJ

[Rain Man]

Current (looking just to next year)

1. T. Gonzalez
2. L. Johnson
3. J. Allen
4. B. Waters
5. T. Green (assumes return to form)
6. D. Colquitt
7. T. Law
8. T. Hali
9. D. Johnson
10. S. Knight.

Current, But Looking to the Future (3-year window)

1. B. Waters
2. L. Johnson
3. T. Gonzalez (still got 4 or 5 good years left)
4. D. Johnson
5. J. Allen (would be #1 except for, you know [raising hand to lips and making glugging sound])
6. T. Hali
7. D. Colquitt
8. B. Pollard
9. P. Surtain
10. R. Edwards

Best All-Time

1. Willie Lanier
2. Will Shields
3. Buck Buchanan
4. Bobby Bell
5. Derrick Thomas
6. Tony Gonzalez
7. Deron Cherry
8. Albert Lewis
9. Jim Tyrer
10. Emmitt Thomas

Best with last names starting with Vowels

1. John Alt
2. Christian Okoye
3. Fred Arbanas
4. Kimble Anders
5. Marcus Allen
6. Jared Allen
7. Louis Aguiar
8. Donnie Edwards
9. Irv Eatman
10. Marvin Upshaw

[Adept Havelock]

Why didn't Otis Taylor make your all time list, Rain Man? Just curious. Great list, either way.

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Who Matriculated at the University of Texas

1. Priest Holmes
2. Keith Cash
3. Bob Simmons
4. Eric Holle
5. Gene Chilton
6. Curtis Jackson
7. Mike Baab
8. Jitter Fields
9. Taje Allen
10. Bill Acker


Top 10 Who Matriculated at a College or University with "Texas" in the Name

1. E.J. Holub - Texas Tech
2. Priest Holmes - U. of Texas
3. Sherrill Headrick - Texas Christian
4. Abner Haynes - North Texas State
5. Dante Hall - Texas A&M
6. Brian Waters - North Texas
7. Mo Moorman - Texas A&M
8. J.T. Smith - North Texas State
9. Tracy Simien - Texas Christian
10. Keith Cash - U. of Texas

[Rain Man]

Why didn't Otis Taylor make your all time list, Rain Man? Just curious. Great list, either way.

The man was my idol and I think a good argument could be made for him, but this is a tough list. I think he or Johnny Robinson or Art Still or Len Dawson or Ed Budde or a couple of other people could've easily made the bottom half of the list.

[Adept Havelock]

The man was my idol and I think a good argument could be made for him, but this is a tough list. I think he or Johnny Robinson or Art Still or Len Dawson or Ed Budde or a couple of other people could've easily made the bottom half of the list.


Thanks...Otis has always been one of my favorite Chiefs as well. Art Still was the only guy worth watching some afternoons...

[Mama Hip Rockets]

Uh, Allen, Page?

LOL is everyone required to put page on their list already?

[Brock]

LOL is everyone required to put page on their list already?

:drool:

[Rain Man]

Thanks...Otis has always been one of my favorite Chiefs as well. Art Still was the only guy worth watching some afternoons...

Otis was the guy I pretended to be on the playgrounds, until I discovered that it was more fun to hit than to be hit.

[Chiefnj2]

How is Eddie Kennison on so many top 10 lists? 55 some-odd receptions for 850 yards for a #1 receiver is weak. His performance in the playoff game was beyond pathetic.

[Hootie]

How is Eddie Kennison on so many top 10 lists? 55 some-odd receptions for 850 yards for a #1 receiver is weak. His performance in the playoff game was beyond pathetic.
he's a very good wide receiver...very underappreciated

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Chiefs with prime jersey numbers

1 Jan Stenerud 3
2 Ed Budde 71
3 Otis Taylor 89
4 Albert Lewis 29
5 Art Still 67
6 Priest Holmes 31
7 Kevin Ross 31
8 Dan Saleaumua 97
9 Joe Montana 19
10 Curley Culp 61

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Chiefs who have worn jersey #87.

1. White, Walter
2. Tommy Brooker
3. Marvin Upshaw
4. Chris Penn
5. Robb Thomas
6. Kevin Lockett
7. Chris Horn
8. Willie Scott
9. Marvin Minnis
10. Rod Jones

[crazycoffey]

LJ
GONZO
WATERS
COLQUITT
KENNISON
LAW
SHIELDS
EDWARDS
ALLEN
DJ


colquitt?

no Hali, surtain, page, wesley? Dustin is better than all these players?


I think you pointed your bolt the wrong way, zeus. :p

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Chiefs players named Will, Willie, or William

1 Willie Lanier
2 Will Shields
3 Willie Roaf
4 Willie Mitchell
5 Willie Davis
6 William White
7 Willie Scott
8 Willie Lee
9 William Bartee
10 Willie Frazier

Top 10 Chiefs players named John or Jon

1 Johnny Robinson
2 John Alt
3 John Browning
4 John Tait
5 Jonathan Hayes
6 Johnnie Morton
7 Jon Gilliam
8 John Welbourne
9 John Matuszak
10 John Huarte

Top 10 Chiefs players named Mike or Michael

1. Mike Garrett
2. Mike Bell
3. Mike Livingston
4. Mike Webster
5. Mike Maslowski
6. Mike Sensibaugh
7. Mike Pruitt
8. Mike Oriard
9. Michael Cloud
10. Mike Mercer

Top 10 Chiefs players named Tom, Dick, or Harry (There are no Dicks or Harry's.)

1 Tommy Brooker
2 Tom Condon
3 Thomas Howard
4 Tom Barndt
5 Tom Baugh
6 Tom Keating
7 Tom Sims
8 Tommie Agee
9 Tom Clements
10 Tom Flores

[Mama Hip Rockets]

colquitt?
no Hali, surtain, page, wesley? Dustin is better than all these players?


well they kind of do different things. you can't really compare a punter to a defensive end, cornerback, or safety.

[Mama Hip Rockets]

Top 10 Chiefs players named John or Jon

1 Johnny Robinson
2 John Alt
3 John Browning
4 John Tait
5 Jonathan Hayes
6 Johnnie Morton
7 Jon Gilliam
8 John Welbourne
9 John Matuszak
10 John Huarte




now i haven't heard of a few of the guys on that list, but if browning, morton, and welbourne can make it, something is wrong.

[whtgldwldr]

1. Larry
2. Tony G
3. Shields
4. Ty Law
5. DJ
6. Edwards
7. Jared
8. Tamba
9. Colquitt (i may never forgive myself for putting a punter in the top 10)
10. Waters

I really really wanted to put Bigfoot Wilson on the list, but i figured i would get laughed off the board if i did. That being said, i wanna see more from number 84.

[Buns]

Top 11 contributers from 2006
1Larry Johnson
2Tamba Hali
3Jared Allen
4Tony Gonzalez
5Brian Waters
6 tye Ty Law Patrick Surtain
8Derrick Johnson
9Dustin Colquitt
10Damon Huard

Top 10 Right Now discounting Colquitt
1LJ
2Tamba
3Allen
4ToGo
5Harris
6Surtain
7Page
8DJ
9Edwards
10Boone

[Wile_E_Coyote]

If Law does not return next season, I can not view it as a huge loss. I'm with Keg, I see Dunn as a bigger loss

[CupidStunt]

1. Tony Gonzalez
2. Larry Johnson
3. Jared Allen
4. Dustin Colquitt
5. Tamba Hali
6. Derrick Johnson
7. Brian Waters
8. Ty Law
9. Eddie Kennison
10. Jarrad Page

I'm not valuing any position higher than another. That's why Colquitt is so high; he is an excellent punter. He's in the same class as a punter as Gonzalez is a tight end, Allen is a DE and LJ an RB.

Waters is low because I have to put a lot of stock in last year's performance, which wasn't great.

I also don't factor in new players yet.

[CupidStunt]

Why are so many people NOT putting Pat Surtain in the top 10, or Law ahead of Surtain. Surtain is the best CB we've had for like five years, which doesn't say much, but he's a hell of a player.

Law was better last year. He came up biggest in clutch situations and wasn't burned much more, if at all.

Surtain didn't really lock anyone down and he certainly didn't make the plays Law did.

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Chiefs who have a Z in their name.

1 Tony Gonzalez
2 Dave Szott
3 Dave Lutz
4 Curt Merz
5 Glenn Cadrez
6 Dan Stryzinski
7 Dave Rozumek
8 John Matuszak
9 Willie Frazier
10 Brian Jozwiak

[Rain Man]

Top 10 Chiefs named Smith

1. Neil Smith
2. J.T. Smith
3. Noland Smith
4. Lucious Smith
5. Sid Smith
6. Jeff Smith (C)
7. Jeff Smith (RB)
8. Fletcher Smith
9. Chris Smith
10. J.J. Smith