Who is better?

[KUCFChiefs]

Who is the greatest defensive tackle in Chiefs history?

[POND_OF_RED]

Well considering Dorsey hasn't played a game yet I'm gonna go ahead and vote for Buck Buchanan and hope my vote changes in the next few years...

[DaneMcCloud]

Eric Downing

[kcxiv]

Ryan Sims someone had to say it.

[Adept Havelock]

:spock:

Buck. However, I have hopes that Glenn Dorsey can play at a similar level.

[milkman]

Every day I wake up and I think to myself that I have already read the dumbest post that I can possibly ever read.

But then I'm proven wrong with a posts like this one.

[Frankie]

This is one stupid poll. No offense n00b. Dorsey hasn't even signed with the Chiefs yet.

SHEESH!

[RNR]

Every day I wake up and I think to myself that I have already read the dumbest post that I can possibly ever read.

But then I've proven wrong with a posts like this one.

ROFL Pretty much sums up my thoughts as well.

[Skip Towne]

Every day I wake up and I think to myself that I have already read the dumbest post that I can possibly ever read.

But then I'm proven wrong with a posts like this one.

That's what keeps us coming back.

[Jenson71]

Keep f@cking doubtin Glenn Dorsey.

[jjchieffan]

Whoa! Getting the cart before the horse aren't you? I hope that Dorsey becomes the best, but to ask this question before he ever signs? Give me a break. :ROFL:

[Mosbonian]

Every day I wake up and I think to myself that I have already read the dumbest post that I can possibly ever read.

But then I'm proven wrong with a posts like this one.

Yeah.....what he said.

mmaddog
*******

[stlchiefs]

Buck couldn't hold up a jersey at the NFL draft the way Dorsey did. Obviously it's Dorsey.

[chiefbowe82]

we clearly got the 2nd best defensive player in the draft, rams took the best off the board in chirs long..dorsey is just another pick, another dt raised by the chiefs he'll be good but nowhere near his potential...this is how you all should look at it rather then he's already in the hall of fame

[StcChief]

Every day I wake up and I think to myself that I have already read the dumbest post that I can possibly ever read.

But then I'm proven wrong with a posts like this one.No doubt about it..... Hope he turns into a Buck DT, but let's get him signed, in camp, on the field.....

check back in 5 years.

[CosmicPal]

Dorsey hasn't even made a history on the field yet.

[milkman]

we clearly got the 2nd best defensive player in the draft, rams took the best off the board in chirs long..dorsey is just another pick, another dt raised by the chiefs he'll be good but nowhere near his potential...this is how you all should look at it rather then he's already in the hall of fame

You can look at it however the hell you want.

Me, I look at at like this.

Dorsey not only was the best defensive player in this draft, but the best player in this draft, period.

Teams ahead of them drafted for need.

Good for them.

That's the way to stay at the top of the draft board for years to come.

[Rain Man]

Right now, I'd probably have to go with Buck Buchanan, but only because of his Super Bowl ring, 2 Super Bowl appearances, AFL championship, 2 AFL championship appearances, 8 all-star game appearances, missing only 1 game in 13 years, the fact that he was the #1 pick overall in his draft, his Hall of Fame bust, and the fact that he's been named by the Sporting News as one of the 100 best players in NFL history.

However, Dorsey is a close second.

[Tribal Warfare]

Where's the Curly Culp option

[CosmicPal]

Right now, I'd probably have to go with Buck Buchanan, but only because of his Super Bowl ring, 2 Super Bowl appearances, AFL championship, 2 AFL championship appearances, 8 all-star game appearances, missing only 1 game in 13 years, the fact that he was the #1 pick overall in his draft, his Hall of Fame bust, and the fact that he's been named by the Sporting News as one of the 100 best players in NFL history.

However, Dorsey is a close second.

ROFL

I beg to differ. :D

[Bowser]

Nate Hobgood-Chittick

[smittysbar]

One guy has never played a down in the NFL..........................great poll............

[DaFace]

This is one stupid poll. No offense n00b. Dorsey hasn't even signed with the Chiefs yet.

SHEESH!

The n00b part is questionable. But at least it's not a poll about our favorite narcotics.

[Rain Man]

I think some of you aren't taking into account Dorsey's forward effects. Kind of like the Doppler when you hear a really loud car coming your way, "Dorsey waves" are already affecting other teams, prompting player retirements and holdouts by offensive players who are afraid to face him.

[Bowser]

I think some of you aren't taking into account Dorsey's forward effects. Kind of like the Doppler when you hear a really loud car coming your way, "Dorsey waves" are already affecting other teams, prompting player retirements and holdouts by offensive players who are afraid to face him.

Dorsey's impact on the playing field will have a ripple effect all along the space-time continuum.

[kstater]

I bet Chuck Norris is better than both of them.

[Pablo]

Here's where I pretend I'm old enough to even have a remote f*cking clue about Buck Buchanan...

Excellent question though.

[milkman]

Here's where I pretend I'm old enough to even have a remote f*cking clue about Buck Buchanan...

Excellent question though.

I hope to hell that "Excellent question" remark is sarcastic.

[Pablo]

I hope to hell that "Excellent question" remark is sarcastic.Yeah, it certainly is.

[Rain Man]

Dorsey's impact on the playing field will have a ripple effect all along the space-time continuum.

Yeah, you have to figure that a bunch of redshirt freshmen and elite high school offensive linemen are asking to switch to the defensive line so they won't eventually have to line up across from him. And probably a lot of quarterbacks in that age range are just flat-out giving up football.

This is big, folks.

[Frankie]

I think some of you aren't taking into account Dorsey's forward effects. Kind of like the Doppler when you hear a really loud car coming your way, "Dorsey waves" are already affecting other teams, prompting player retirements and holdouts by offensive players who are afraid to face him.

Ah the good days when we had all that and more with the much feared "Scanlon Waves."

[Rain Man]

Here's where I pretend I'm old enough to even have a remote f*cking clue about Buck Buchanan...

Excellent question though.

In those days, tackles and guards went about 250 lbs. and almost none were at 260. Centers went about 240 to 250.

Now add in Buck Buchanan who weighed in at 285 to 290, and was faster than most of them.

It'd be the equivalent of having a 350-lb. defensive tackle today who is the most mobile guy on your defensive line. The dominance of Buck Buchanan cannot be overestimated.

[Adept Havelock]

In those days, tackles and guards went about 250 lbs. and almost none were at 260. Centers went about 240 to 250.

Now add in Buck Buchanan who weighed in at 285 to 290, and was faster than most of them.

It'd be the equivalent of having a 350-lb. defensive tackle today who is the most mobile guy on your defensive line. The dominance of Buck Buchanan cannot be overestimated.

Good way to put it. GonzoRox88, in modern terms think Tony Siragusa with Warren Sapp's (in his prime) ability to move. One of the most dominating D-Linemen I've ever seen play.