Did fair trade or rip off?

[Nightfyre]

I offered Eli manning and kevin smith (smiff) for MJD. He was weak at QB and my RB2 is willis mcgahee. Did I rip him off?

[Mecca]

I had Jones-Drew last he's kind of up and down...

[Nightfyre]

I had Jones-Drew last he's kind of up and down...

I'm hoping he can get the ball more consistently this year.

[Mecca]

He probably won't they still have Fred Taylor...

Having Jones-Drew is extremely frustrating 1 week he'll be great the next he'll have 20 yards, it's a guessing game of when to start him and half the time you'll be wrong and then you'll be pissed about it.

[Nightfyre]

maybe I can package him with a wideout and flip them for Westbrook. The guy with westbrook has the weakest wr corp ever.

[OnTheWarpath15]

Who has a fantasy draft before the preseason even starts?

[Nightfyre]

Who has a fantasy draft before the preseason even starts?

it was just some random yahoo draft.

[Hootie]

QB's like Eli are a dime a dozen in FFL (assuming it is standard scoring)...if MJD was a full time starter he'd be a top tier back...he still has more value than Eli, though...so yes, you won the deal but no, I wouldn't consider it a TOTAL rape...

[Buck]

yay its the first rate my trade/draft thread of the year.

YOU WIN THE PRIZE

[Predarat]

I rate this trade about an E.

[007]

Who has a fantasy draft before the preseason even starts?

No shit!!! I won't have my draft until after the 3rd preseason game at the earliest. Have to wait to see if there are any major injuries so nobody goes into the season limping.

[Shaid]

I'm not a big MJD fan because it always seems that if you start him, he does nothing or if you sit him, he goes off. He's a very frustrating back. If Taylor goes down though, he'd be fantastic.

[JuicesFlowing]

Fred Taylor is still alive? Cool.

[Mile High Mania]

Kinda depends on what you're left with at QB and how your league scoring is set up.

Is it PPR, I would hope so since you acquired MJD.

If Kevin Smith does what many project him to do in DET, then he may only be a few 100 yards and maybe 2-4 TDs behind MJD, but I can't say about PPR right now - just don't know enough about how he will play.

Overall not a bad deal at all for you, but who you have left at QB and the scoring really decides this one and you didn't share that info. You can't really grade a trade without knowing the scoring, the lineup requirements, etc.