Football Poll: Super Bowl vs. Hall of Fame

[Rain Man]

Which would you rather be?


A mid-level NFL star who wins the Super Bowl but isn't a realistic Hall of Fame candidate (example: Tarik Glenn, Mark Bavaro, Jim Kiick, Tom Rathman, etc.)

A top-tier NFL star who makes the Hall of Fame but never won or appeared in a Super Bowl. (Examples: Earl Campbell, Barry Sanders, Will Shields, Derrick Thomas, etc.)

[MoreLemonPledge]

There are less Hall of Famers than Super Bowl winners. I'd want a gold jacket.

[cdcox]

Which would you rather be?


A mid-level NFL star who wins the Super Bowl but isn't a realistic Hall of Fame candidate (example: Tarik Glenn, Mark Bavaro, Jim Kiick, Tom Rathman, etc.)

A top-tier NFL star who makes the Hall of Fame but never won or appeared in a Super Bowl. (Examples: Earl Campbell, Barry Sanders, Will Shields, Derrick Thomas, etc.)

I'd rather have the glory of winning a SB. I'd rather be Fred Arbanas than Tony G.

[jjchieffan]

Give me the Superbowl ring. Nothing like being a champion.

[Rain Man]

Maybe I'm selfish, but I went with the Hall of Fame. It's the elite of the elite.

[Thig Lyfe]

I went with Super Bowl. That's supposed to be the goal every season, right?

[acesn8s]

Hall of Famer. They make more money.

[Norman Einstein]

Which would you rather be?


A mid-level NFL star who wins the Super Bowl but isn't a realistic Hall of Fame candidate (example: Tarik Glenn, Mark Bavaro, Jim Kiick, Tom Rathman, etc.)

A top-tier NFL star who makes the Hall of Fame but never won or appeared in a Super Bowl. (Examples: Earl Campbell, Barry Sanders, Will Shields, Derrick Thomas, etc.)

How many of the Chiefs that are in the HOF have SB rings?

[Micjones]

The 53rd player on an NFL roster can win a Superbowl ring.
Canton only recognizes those who've made the best individual contributions to the game.

[Slainte]

Painful as it would be to have had an NFL career and no ring to show for it, I think I'd rather be known by my elite talents on the field. Canton or bust...

[Molitoth]

HOF for sure. Scrubs have SB rings.

[Pushead2]

HOF for sure. Scrubs have SB rings.

http://www.everyjoe.com/emqb/files/2008/03/mitchell_kawika.jpg

[dirk digler]

Definitely HOF

[BigMeatballDave]

SB

[-King-]

I'd rather be in the exclusive club of the best of the best. Hall of fame for me.
Posted via Mobile Device

[Frazod]

Super Bowl. I'll bet Dan Marino would kill for Trent Dilfer's ring.