Chiefs Trivia QB performances.

[Dave Lane]

Without looking at the stats, who do you believe had the worst QB performance:

Tyler Palko 2011
Matt Cassel 2012
Brady Quinn 2012

Answer quick with just your gut feeling.

[Dave Lane]

Just curious to settle a disagreement.

[BlackHelicopters]

Quinn

[ptlyon]

Peyton Manning

[Bearcat]

Which sub-100 yard performance that I probably turned off by halftime, if I watched at all, was the worst? The Chiefs should disband for simply having so many to choose from.

Tough choice between Cassel vs Balitomore and Palko vs Pittsburgh (and a few others :banghead: )...

[TEX]

Where's the Brodie Croyle option?

[ptlyon]

Where's the Brodie Croyle option?

Ricky Stanzi was perfect

[Chief Roundup]

Where is the Thigpen option. He was worse than Palko.

[RealSNR]

Where is the Thigpen option. He was worse than Palko.

Thigpen at least scored some points.

Palko did nothing of the sort

[Dayze]

easily Cassel.

[AdumbGuy]

Don't give a shit about the stats. Matt Cassel is/was/will-forever-be the worst quarterback in the history of the world. I saw it.

[patteeu]

I voted Brady Quinn, but it might just be because he underperformed compared to my expectations to a greater degree than the other two. I had high hopes for at least a significant upgrade over Cassel's recent performances when he took over, but if anything he was worse.

[AdumbGuy]

I voted Brady Quinn, but it might just be because he underperformed compared to my expectations to a greater degree than the other two. I had high hopes for at least a significant upgrade over Cassel's recent performances when he took over, but if anything he was worse.

I dunno. I thought quinn's inaccurate misfires and checkdowns had more zip on them. Considering everything else was the same, I'd say that makes him better.

[Chief Roundup]

Thigpen at least scored some points.

Palko did nothing of the sort

He didn't.. Palko is the one that threw the TD that helped us beat the Bears. We should have lost that game. And the ones after Romeo replaced Haley. We might have actually gotten a real QB. Not that we would have known what to do with one anyway.

[Chief Roundup]

I picked Quinn because he couldn't come in and look better than Cassel.
If you can't look better than Cassel. You probably suck bad.

[Rasputin]

Palko > Cassel > Quinn


Palko did a hail marry at the end of half time & (somehow) hit MidgetMcCluster for the actual game winning TD. Cassel on the other hand heaved a hail marry pass at the end of a game to be a hero and struck the goal post.

[Dayze]

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Matt-Cassel-Celebration-Fail.gif

/thread

[ptlyon]

Cassel on the other hand heaved a hail marry pass at the end of a game to be a hero and struck the goal post.

:BS: he cant throw it that far

[Rasputin]

:BS: he cant throw it that far

true story bro

http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w288/30katania/animated%20stuff/funny-dance-pony-dancing-deal-with-it-animated-gif-pics_zpsdf83e436.gif (http://media.photobucket.com/user/30katania/media/animated%20stuff/funny-dance-pony-dancing-deal-with-it-animated-gif-pics_zpsdf83e436.gif.html)

[AdumbGuy]

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Matt-Cassel-Celebration-Fail.gif

/thread

You know, I've seen this gif a billion times before and chuckled, but for some reason, I'm only now realizing the immense magnitude of asshattery needed to pull this off. Did he have a stroke, mid-jump? How the hell did he manage to screw up jumping into somebody that badly?

[Dayze]

what makes it beautiful is it seems like he thought his right foot would hit the ground. lol

[AdumbGuy]

what makes it beautiful is it seems like he thought his right foot would hit the ground. lol

hah. The thing is he was using his damn hands. It's not like he got shoulder bumped or undercut or something. He was bracing for the impact!

[cosmo20002]

I never saw Palko or Quinn screw up putting on a hat, so I'm gonna say Castle is the worst.

[lcarus]

As far as brutal fanbases go, we're probably ranked like 28th in the league. And we were happy that our QB got knocked the fuck out. I'd go with Cassel just based on that. Guy was so bad he turned Arrowhead into Franklin Field circa 1968. We would have booed Santa too last season.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

How the fuck is Matt Cassel not leading this? Yep, my faith in the overall intelligence of this fan base just grows and grows...

[Ebolapox]

How the **** is Matt Cassel not leading this? Yep, my faith in the overall intelligence of this fan base just grows and grows...

did you not read the OP? the idea is to vote who you guessed was the worst STATISTICALLY SPEAKING in those years. it has nothing to do with personal opinion, it's trying to answer a TRIVIA QUESTION

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

did you not read the OP? the idea is to vote who you guessed was the worst STATISTICALLY SPEAKING in those years. it has nothing to do with personal opinion, it's trying to answer a TRIVIA QUESTION

Ah, my bad. I just see Matt Cassel and instantly assume he should be number one in every aspect of suckage.

[Dave Lane]

Thigpen at least scored some points.

Palko did nothing of the sort

Actually Palko was the best of all three. In order statistically it's would be:

Worst

Brady Quinn 2012

Matt Cassel 2012

Tyler Palko. 2011


Palko actually had almost a 60% completion rate and threw less picks per attempt than either Cassel or Quinn.

Someone was swearing Palko was the worst QB in history and I said really bad but not that horrid.

[rockymtnchief]

I never saw Palko or Quinn screw up putting on a hat, so I'm gonna say Castle is the worst.

Shit!!! For the first time ever, I have to agree with Cosmo. :banghead::thumb:

[OrtonsPiercedTaint]

and Stanzi never played one NLF snap. Pioli was a QB guru...

[AussieChiefsFan]

LMAO at all the people saying Cassel.

[Rasputin]

Actually Palko was the best of all three. In order statistically it's would be:

Worst

Brady Quinn 2012

Matt Cassel 2012

Tyler Palko. 2011


Palko actually had almost a 60% completion rate and threw less picks per attempt than either Cassel or Quinn.

Someone was swearing Palko was the worst QB in history and I said really bad but not that horrid.

Weren't we in a dog fight with the Steelers with Palko at QB that year? Is when we took them into ot & knocked the fuck out of Ben Rothlessburger?

[Gadzooks]

Actually Palko was the best of all three. In order statistically it's would be:

Worst

Brady Quinn 2012

Matt Cassel 2012

Tyler Palko. 2011


Palko actually had almost a 60% completion rate and threw less picks per attempt than either Cassel or Quinn.

Someone was swearing Palko was the worst QB in history and I said really bad but not that horrid.

Great... You blew the whole fuckin' thread.

The premise was dumb to begin with. Why don't you start a poll asking who scored the most goals in the NHL, or, which show was the most successful while Ted McGinley was on their active roster?

Boooooooo Dave. This thread sucks!!!

BTW - Tyler Thigpen is the best QB the Chiefs have had in the 21st century. (Just my opinion).

[Mama Hip Rockets]

Where is the Thigpen option. He was worse than Palko.

Absurd.

[Mama Hip Rockets]

You know, I've seen this gif a billion times before and chuckled, but for some reason, I'm only now realizing the immense magnitude of asshattery needed to pull this off. Did he have a stroke, mid-jump? How the hell did he manage to screw up jumping into somebody that badly?

ROFL

[Mama Hip Rockets]

Tyler Palko is far and away the worst QB on this list.

[GoShox]

Weren't we in a dog fight with the Steelers with Palko at QB that year? Is when we took them into ot & knocked the **** out of Ben Rothlessburger?

Yeah, we lost to the Steelers during Palko's year by four points and Palko threw three INTs

The OT game was last year

[notorious]

Yes.

[notorious]

Thigpen is Joe fucking Montana compared to Palko.

[ClevelandBronco]

I would be neither Cleveland nor Bronco if I didn't vote for Quinn.

[Gadzooks]

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-stylyAxGfdo/TyvdOtJU9jI/AAAAAAAAZAM/ws0K2EFJxzo/s1600/00.jpg

[Dixie Land]

DAMNIT voted ASmith

[patteeu]

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-stylyAxGfdo/TyvdOtJU9jI/AAAAAAAAZAM/ws0K2EFJxzo/s1600/00.jpg

I'm about an hour into The Rich Eisen Podcast as I open ChiefsPlanet for the first time this morning. The first link I click on is the link to this post (most recent post since the last time I read this thread) just as Matthew Berry is discussing the fact that he worked on Married With Children with Ted McGinley. Weird coincidence.

[KC_Lee]

Where's the All of the Above option?

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Ted McGinley was a Quarterback. Bring him in?

http://images.marketplaceadvisor.channeladvisor.com/hi/6/5956/lcrotnerds3.jpg

[Fat Elvis]

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/Matt-Cassel-Celebration-Fail.gif

/thread

That is as close to a receiver he got all last year.

[Rausch]

I can't believe this is close.

Tyler Palko was not even an NFL practice squad level guy.

[Dave Lane]

Actually, statistically Palko was the best of the group. With a pretty good lead.

[Predarat]

cAssHole is the worst ever and the worst there ever will be, hell even Pelluer > cAssHole

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Don't give a shit about the stats. Matt Cassel is/was/will-forever-be the worst quarterback in the history of the world. I saw it.

The gayest, girliest, throwing motion I have ever seen.

[loochy]

I can't believe this is close.

Tyler Palko was not even an NFL practice squad level guy.

Ok, then what does that say about Quinn and Cassel?

[AdumbGuy]

Ok, then what does that say about Quinn and Cassel?

The most damning thing about Cassel, the reason why he was objectively the worst quarterback in the league by far for the last few years - he's old! All the other comparably craptacular qbs, the gabberts, the sanchezzes - they were at least prospects failing or journeymen forced into action through injury. We fucking willfully started Casshole!