Comparison Draft Idea

[CaliforniaChief]

Anyone up for a little comparison drafting off the same draft board?

Fanspeak.com has about 7 or 8 draft boards up, will let you do a complete 7-round draft WITH the compensatory selections and traded picks up there. If we all used the same board, it would give us a good common base (even if we still dispute a player's availability) to go from.

If you're up for it, then let's decide which board to use...

Optimum Scouting, Matt Miller, Draft TV, Mocking the Draft. Which one would you prefer?

[The Franchise]

Fanspeak has Kevin White at #8. Drafttek has White at #14.

[CaliforniaChief]

Which board overall do you think is the best of the ones they have? I'd just like to see us pick one (flawed though it may be) so we have the same basis for picks.

[The Franchise]

Ehh....it's really the flip of a coin. I guess you could go with Fanspeak's board.

[kccrow]

All of those boards are a joke, which is what makes fanspeak a joke. I wouldn't use a single one. I might consider, and that is a big maybe, New Era's (Matt Miller). The rest you could flush down the toilet.

[The Franchise]

Using Miller's board.....I pulled this.

1: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS WASHINGTON
2: R2P17
ILB BENARDRICK MCKINNEY MISSISSIPPI STATE
3: R3P16
OT ROB HAVENSTEIN WISCONSIN
4: R3P34
WR JUSTIN HARDY EAST CAROLINA
5: R4P19
TE JEFF HEUERMAN OHIO STATE
6: R5P36
S CODY PREWITT OLE MISS
7: R5P37
G JAMIL DOUGLAS ARIZONA STATE
8: R6P17
WR DARREN WALLER GEORGIA TECH
9: R6P42
DE ANTHONY CHICKILLO MIAMI (FLA.)
10: R7P16
QB SEAN MANNION OREGON STATE

[CaliforniaChief]

Alright, let's do Miller's. I'll work one up now.

[kccrow]

Using Miller's board.....I pulled this.

1: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS WASHINGTON
2: R2P17
ILB BENARDRICK MCKINNEY MISSISSIPPI STATE
3: R3P16
OT ROB HAVENSTEIN WISCONSIN
4: R3P34
WR JUSTIN HARDY EAST CAROLINA
5: R4P19
TE JEFF HEUERMAN OHIO STATE
6: R5P36
S CODY PREWITT OLE MISS
7: R5P37
G JAMIL DOUGLAS ARIZONA STATE
8: R6P17
WR DARREN WALLER GEORGIA TECH
9: R6P42
DE ANTHONY CHICKILLO MIAMI (FLA.)
10: R7P16
QB SEAN MANNION OREGON STATE

Very similar to what I got:

18: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS
WASHINGTON


49: R2P17
WR DEVIN SMITH
OHIO STATE


80: R3P16
OT DONOVAN SMITH
PENN STATE


98: R3P34
TE JEFF HEUERMAN
OHIO STATE


118: R4P19
WR RASHAD GREENE
FLORIDA STATE


172: R5P36
DT BOBBY RICHARDSON
INDIANA


173: R5P37
OT ROBERT MYERS
TENNESSEE STATE


192: R6P17
S CLAYTON GEATHERS
UCF


217: R6P42
ILB ZACH VIGIL
UTAH STATE


233: R7P16
ILB BRYCE HAGER
BAYLOR

[Nightfyre]

Very similar to what I got:

18: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS
WASHINGTON


49: R2P17
WR DEVIN SMITH
OHIO STATE


80: R3P16
OT DONOVAN SMITH
PENN STATE


98: R3P34
TE JEFF HEUERMAN
OHIO STATE


118: R4P19
WR RASHAD GREENE
FLORIDA STATE


172: R5P36
DT BOBBY RICHARDSON
INDIANA


173: R5P37
OT ROBERT MYERS
TENNESSEE STATE


192: R6P17
S CLAYTON GEATHERS
UCF


217: R6P42
ILB ZACH VIGIL
UTAH STATE


233: R7P16
ILB BRYCE HAGER
BAYLOR

A++

[milkman]

A++

+

[OldSchool]

Go with realistic prospects or take the top available dudes? Just ran my first sim and Winston, White, Peters, Beasley, and Scherff were all available at pick 18.

[The Franchise]

Go with realistic prospects or take the top available dudes? Just ran my first sim and Winston, White, Peters, Beasley, and Scherff were all available at pick 18.

Yeah....if something screwy happens....I just restart that shit.

[CaliforniaChief]

Ok, here's my best shot:

1.18: Devante Parker, WR, Louisville (Yep, he was up there.)
2.17: Maxx Williams, TE, Minnesota
3.16: Ereck Flowers, OT, Miami (FL)
3.34: Senquez Golson, CB, Mississippi
4.19: Sammie Coates, WR, Auburn
5.36: Shaquille Mason, C/G, Georgia Tech
5.37: Chris Hackett, S, Texas Christian
6.17: Trey Williams, RB, Texas A&M
6.42: Anthony Chickillo, DE, Miami (FL)
7.16: Robert Myers, OT, Tennessee-Chattanooga

[Nightfyre]

Ok, here's my best shot:

1.18: Devante Parker, WR, Louisville (Yep, he was up there.)
2.17: Maxx Williams, TE, Minnesota
3.16: Ereck Flowers, OT, Miami (FL)
3.34: Senquez Golson, CB, Mississippi
4.19: Sammie Coates, WR, Auburn
5.36: Shaquille Mason, C/G, Georgia Tech
5.37: Chris Hackett, S, Texas Christian
6.17: Trey Williams, RB, Texas A&M
6.42: Anthony Chickillo, DE, Miami (FL)
7.16: Robert Myers, OT, Tennessee-Chattanooga

I would say the (Yep, he was there.) applies to the entire draft save 3.34, 5.36 and 6.17.

[Direckshun]

Stay realistic, if you can. I'm thinking its increasingly likely that Parker makes it to our pick, though.

[CaliforniaChief]

I just followed who was available on the board we were using, realizing that it's nearly impossible to know for sure how realistic it really is. I thought it was cool to have all of us use the same board of available players to see who we'd choose.

[The Franchise]

Odd that Marcus Peters usually falls to our pick.....especially considering he's rated #6 overall.

[Direckshun]

Matt Miller's board, keeping it realistic:

1. Erving
2. Devin Smith
3. Lockett
3. CB D'Joun Smith, Florida Atlantic
4. OT Donovan Smith, Penn State
5. TE Jesse James, Penn State
5. DE/OLB Zach Wagenmenn, Montana
6. NT Joey Mbu, Houston
6. QB Sean Mannion, Oregon State
7. DE Travis Raciti, San Jose State

[Direckshun]

Odd that Marcus Peters usually falls to our pick.....especially considering he's rated #6 overall.

I think it's 90% likely he's there when we pick.

Are the character concerns enough for Dorsey/Reid. That's the question.

They'd be enough for me, but that's just me.

[Urc Burry]

Peters and DGB are impossible to gauge where they are going in the draft. They will both probably be there for our first, and possibly even our second. More so DGB

I love Peters though. My favorite corner in the draft.. If only he weren't such a diva. I think he is worth the risk in the first though

[Direckshun]

I think Peters is going in the first. He needs a good team with a (very) strong locker room.

[Urc Burry]

Revis just confirmed we were chasing him.. It'll be interesting to see where we target a corner

[Direckshun]

Very true.

Wayne
Peters
Johnson
Collins

Who knows.

[O.city]

Peters could be a legit elite top 5 CB in the league. If he's therr, wou ld all depend on the off field

[CaliforniaChief]

The two top corners (Waynes and Peters) couldn't be any different from each other.

I would take Waynes if they were both there, but if IF Peters can keep his act together, and I'd like our locker room as much as any to help him, he's a top 5 talent and could be the next Revis Island, IMO.

If you're drafting at #18 and he's still there, you've got to think long and hard about that one.

[KevB]

Peters could be a legit elite top 5 CB in the league. If he's therr, wou ld all depend on the off field

Reid seems like a coach who has confidence he can get the best out of a player with Peter's background. Players generally have nothing but really positive things to say about Reid. Nobody is mocking Peters to the Chiefs, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if we picked the guy. His reconciliation with the Washington coaching staff would seem to speak pretty well of him.

[YayMike]

Very similar to what I got:

18: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS
WASHINGTON


49: R2P17
WR DEVIN SMITH
OHIO STATE


80: R3P16
OT DONOVAN SMITH
PENN STATE


98: R3P34
TE JEFF HEUERMAN
OHIO STATE


118: R4P19
WR RASHAD GREENE
FLORIDA STATE


172: R5P36
DT BOBBY RICHARDSON
INDIANA


173: R5P37
OT ROBERT MYERS
TENNESSEE STATE


192: R6P17
S CLAYTON GEATHERS
UCF


217: R6P42
ILB ZACH VIGIL
UTAH STATE


233: R7P16
ILB BRYCE HAGER
BAYLOR


Holy Shit, if we could get this!!!!!

[DC.chief]

18: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS
WASHINGTON

49: R2P17
WR NELSON AGHOLOR
USC

80: R3P16
C HRONISS GRASU
OREGON

98: R3P34
WR SAMMIE COATES
AUBURN

118: R4P19
TE CLIVE WALFORD
MIAMI (FLA.)

172: R5P36
OT JEREMIAH POUTASI
UTAH

173: R5P37
ILB MIKE HULL
PENN STATE

192: R6P17
S DURELL ESKRIDGE
SYRACUSE

217: R6P42
OT SEAN HICKEY
SYRACUSE

233: R7P16
DT JAMES CASTLEMAN
OKLAHOMA STATE

[CaliforniaChief]

I like Clive Walford. Think he'd be a nice option in our offense.

[kccrow]

Holy Shit, if we could get this!!!!!

LOL yep... I'd probably shit myself and pass out.

[Direckshun]

The two top corners (Waynes and Peters) couldn't be any different from each other.

I would take Waynes if they were both there, but if IF Peters can keep his act together, and I'd like our locker room as much as any to help him, he's a top 5 talent and could be the next Revis Island, IMO.

If you're drafting at #18 and he's still there, you've got to think long and hard about that one.

A guy who fights with coaches?

I'd have to think Dorsey passes. I might, too. I can't put up with that shit, but partially that's because I don't see him as the All Pro others see him as.

[Saccopoo]

A guy who fights with coaches?

I'd have to think Dorsey passes. I might, too. I can't put up with that shit, but partially that's because I don't see him as the All Pro others see him as.

PJ Williams.

[The Franchise]

18: R1P18
CB MARCUS PETERS WASHINGTON
49: R2P17
ILB BENARDRICK MCKINNEY MISSISSIPPI STATE
80: R3P16
G A.J. CANN SOUTH CAROLINA
98: R3P34
WR JUSTIN HARDY EAST CAROLINA
118: R4P19
OT DONOVAN SMITH PENN STATE
172: R5P36
S CODY PREWITT OLE MISS
173: R5P37
TE JESSE JAMES PENN STATE
193: R6P17
C MAX GARCIA FLORIDA
217: R6P41
DT DAVID PARRY STANFORD
233: R7P16
ILB ZACH VIGIL UTAH STATE

[CaliforniaChief]

One of the later round WR's I've seen is Darren Waller from Georgia Tech. Looks like a raw prospect with some great physical dimensions, 6'6", 238, 4.46 40 time.

Anyone know more about him?

[The Franchise]

Try the CBS Sports Board.....it seems to be a little more realistic....at least to me.

[The Franchise]

Well....somewhat realistic.

[The Franchise]

Offense fixed.

18: R1P18
QB JAMEIS WINSTON FLORIDA STATE
49: R2P17
WR NELSON AGHOLOR SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
80: R3P16
TE CLIVE WALFORD MIAMI (FLA.)
98: R3P34
CB D'JOUN SMITH FLORIDA ATLANTIC
118: R4P19
OT DONOVAN SMITH PENN STATE
172: R5P36
C SHAQUILLE MASON GEORGIA TECH
173: R5P37
OG JEREMIAH POUTASI UTAH
193: R6P17
CB LADARIUS GUNTER MIAMI (FLA.)
217: R6P41
WR ANTWAN GOODLEY BAYLOR
233: R7P16
DE OBUM GWACHAM OREGON STATE

[Saccopoo]

One of the later round WR's I've seen is Darren Waller from Georgia Tech. Looks like a raw prospect with some great physical dimensions, 6'6", 238, 4.46 40 time.

Anyone know more about him?

Deandre Smelter was the guy at WR for the Yellow Jackets this past year - until he blew his knee late in the season against Georgia.

One of the best receivers in the college football and because he doesn't play his last two games, he's almost a draft footnote.

Somebody is going to pick him up later in the draft and get an absolute steal. Guy is really, really good with a huge ceiling.

His running mate Waller is a bit bigger, but he's not the football player Smelter is. He is stiff catching the ball, runs bad routes, has stiff hips and doesn't have a very good feel for the ball when it's in the air.

He's fearless and tough. Should be considered a tight end project at the next level versus a WR.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/gR8GhCSf8FY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

[kccrow]

Deandre Smelter was the guy at WR for the Yellow Jackets this past year - until he blew his knee late in the season against Georgia.

One of the best receivers in the college football and because he doesn't play his last two games, he's almost a draft footnote.

Somebody is going to pick him up later in the draft and get an absolute steal. Guy is really, really good with a huge ceiling.

His running mate Waller is a bit bigger, but he's not the football player Smelter is. He is stiff catching the ball, runs bad routes, has stiff hips and doesn't have a very good feel for the ball when it's in the air.

He's fearless and tough. Should be considered a tight end project at the next level versus a WR.

<iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/gR8GhCSf8FY" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="315" width="560"></iframe>

+1

[The Franchise]

18: R1P18
WR DEVANTE PARKER LOUISVILLE
49: R2P17
CB P.J. WILLIAMS FLORIDA STATE
80: R3P16
ILB RAMIK WILSON GEORGIA
98: R3P34
G ALI MARPET HOBART
118: R4P19
TE JEFF HEUERMAN OHIO STATE
172: R5P36
OT JEREMIAH POUTASI UTAH
173: R5P37
S KURTIS DRUMMOND MICHIGAN STATE
193: R6P17
WR DEANDRE SMELTER GEORGIA TECH
217: R6P41
ILB ZACH VIGIL UTAH STATE
233: R7P16
DT LOUIS TRINCA-PASAT IOWA

[royalschiefs]

18: R1P18
OT JAKE FISHER OREGON
49: R2P17
CB KEVIN JOHNSON WAKE FOREST
80: R3P16
WR TYLER LOCKETT KANSAS STATE
98: R3P34
G ALI MARPET HOBART
118: R4P19
TE JEFF HEUERMAN OHIO STATE
172: R5P36
ILB MIKE HULL PENN STATE
173: R5P37
S CODY PREWITT OLE MISS
193: R6P17
RB TYLER VARGA YALE
217: R6P41
ILB ZACH VIGIL UTAH STATE
233: R7P16
WR JORDAN TAYLOR RICE

[Snapplez]

18: R1P18
C CAMERON ERVING
FLORIDA STATE
49: R2P17
WR DORIAL GREEN-BECKHAM
MISSOURI
80: R3P16
G LAKEN TOMLINSON
DUKE
98: R3P34
WR TYLER LOCKETT
KANSAS STATE
118: R4P19
TE JEFF HEUERMAN
OHIO STATE
172: R5P36
CB QUANDRE DIGGS
TEXAS
173: R5P37
CB LADARIUS GUNTER
MIAMI
193: R6P17
ILB TREY DEPRIEST
ALABAMA
217: R6P41
DT CHUCKY HUNTER
TCU
233: R7P16
OLB XZAVIER DICKSON
ALABAMA

[DC.chief]

18: R1P18
WR DEVANTE PARKER
LOUISVILLE

49: R2P17
C CAM ERVING
FLORIDA STATE

80: R3P16
CB RONALD DARBY
FLORIDA STATE

98: R3P34
WR TYLER LOCKETT
KANSAS STATE

118: R4P19
TE JEFF HUERMAN
OHIO STATE

172: R5P36
ILB TAIWAN JONES
MICHIGAN STATE

173: R5P37
OT SEAN HICKEY
SYRACUSE

[BigChiefFan]

18: R1P18
WR DEVANTE PARKER
LOUISVILLE

49: R2P17
C CAM ERVING
FLORIDA STATE

80: R3P16
CB RONALD DARBY
FLORIDA STATE

98: R3P34
WR TYLER LOCKETT
KANSAS STATE

118: R4P19
TE JEFF HUERMAN
OHIO STATE

172: R5P36
ILB TAIWAN JONES
MICHIGAN STATE

173: R5P37
OT SEAN HICKEY
SYRACUSE

That's a nice draft. Good job!!

[The Franchise]

That's a nice draft. Good job!!

Nice but obviously unrealistic.

[CaliforniaChief]

18: R1P18
CB JALEN COLLINS
LSU

49: R2P17
OT ANDRUS PEAT
STANFORD

80: R3P16
TE CLIVE WALFORD
MIAMI (FLA.)

98: R3P34
WR TYLER LOCKETT
KANSAS STATE

118: R4P19
ILB TAIWAN JONES
MICHIGAN STATE

172: R5P36
S CODY PREWITT
OLE MISS

173: R5P37
DT BOBBY RICHARDSON
INDIANA

193: R6P17
DT DERRICK LOTT
TENNESSEE-CHATTANOGA

217: R6P41
C MAX GARCIA
FLORIDA

233: R7P16
WR MARIO ALFORD
WEST VIRGINIA

[The Franchise]

1: R1P18
DE RANDY GREGORY NEBRASKA
2: R2P17
WR NELSON AGHOLOR USC
3: R3P16
TE CLIVE WALFORD MIAMI (FLA.)
4: R3P34
OT ROB HAVENSTEIN WISCONSIN
5: R4P19
CB IFO EKPRE-OLOMU OREGON
6: R5P36
S CODY PREWITT OLE MISS
7: R5P37
DT ELLIS MCCARTHY UCLA
8: R6P17
C MAX GARCIA FLORIDA
9: R6P41
WR DEANDRE SMELTER GEORGIA TECH
10: R7P16
ILB ZACH VIGIL UTAH STATE

[The Franchise]

They have Walterfootball's board up on it now.

18: R1P18
CB TRAE WAYNES MICHIGAN STATE
49: R2P17
WR PHILLIP DORSETT MIAMI
80: R3P16
C HRONISS GRASU OREGON
98: R3P34
RB JAY AJAYI BOISE STATE
118: R4P19
CB IFO EKPRE-OLOMU OREGON
172: R5P36
OT ROB HAVENSTEIN WISCONSIN
173: R5P37
WR CHRIS CONLEY GEORGIA
193: R6P17
ILB HAYES PULLARD USC
217: R6P41
TE WES SAXTON SOUTH ALABAMA
233: R7P16
S TEVIN MCDONALD EASTERN WASHINGTON

[KevB]

Used Walter

18: R1P18
WR DEVANTE PARKER
LOUISVILLE

49: R2P17
ILB STEPHONE ANTHONY
CLEMSON

80: R3P16
OT CEDRIC OGBUHEI
TEXAS A&M

98: R3P34
CB IFO EKPRE-OLOMU
OREGON

118: R4P19
TE CLIVE WALFORD
MIAMI

172: R5P36
WR CHRIS CONLEY
GEORGIA

173: R5P37
G SHAQUILLE MASON
GEORGIA TECH

193: R6P17
S ADRIAN AMOS
PENN STATE

217: R6P41
DT DAVID PARRY
STANFORD

233: R7P16
WR TONY LIPPETT
MICHIGAN STATE