PDA

View Full Version : Mock (4/2)


Direckshun
04-02-2015, 12:14 PM
Assumptions:

1. S Eric Berry is placed on NFI list and is paid something harmless to our cap.

2. The Chiefs sign the following free agents:

On with the show:

1.18. CB Kevin Johnson, Wake Forest

My (realistic) choice for the Chiefs has essentially whittled down to two players: Cam Erving at center, and Kevin Johnson at corner. Both players fill immediate areas of need. Erving would start immediately at either C or RT. Johnson would replace the likely-departing Sean Smith in 2016 (or, even better, Smith is extended and the Chiefs have two starting CBs on the outside who are at least 6'2"). I think Johnson can start right now over Phillip Gaines, who I still really like, and combined with Smith, Gaines, and Jamel Flemming, keep the Chiefs secondary in the Top 5.

Johnson lacks elite speed, but that's what Gaines is ostensibly for. His skillset is extremely similar to Sean Smith, who is a bit bigger and a bit more athletic but lacks Johnson's intense mean streak. Smith is a true #1 when the "light is on," but a liability when it flickers off. Johnson's light never goes off, and exhibits an intensity our secondary has lacked since losing Brandon Flowers.

The question does become -- can the Chiefs seriously draft a CB with non-elite speed? I have my doubts, as I selected Jalen Collins last time around. But Johnson needs to be a serious, serious consideration assuming he lasts to us, which I think he will.

2.49. WR Devin Smith, Ohio State

I typically try to be more creative than this, just selecting the same guy over and over again. I promise I'll do better for the remainder of the mock.

3.80. C Reese Dismukes, Auburn

Dismukes is definitely underrated on this board. He doesn't sport outstanding measurables but he is a starter-caliber center that you can plug in right away. If the Chiefs elect to pass on Cam Erving in the 1st, it is possible that they try to land a technique-solid center who can start immediately on day two.

3.98. OLB Lorenzo Mauldin, Louisville

Mauldin is every bit the prospect his teammate Marcus Smith was last year. Smith was dramatically overdrafted in the 1st round, and since Mauldin carries all the weaknesses of Smith (and isn't the top-end athlete Smith is/was), we'll have a major course correction and he'll be available here at this point in the draft.

The Chiefs have to have contingency plans for life after Hali and Houston, if it ever gets that far. Mauldin/Ford is a start.

4.118. TE Tyler Kroft, Rutgers

It's easier to teach a good receiver to adequately block than it is to teach a good blocker to adequately receive. Kroft has already shown an adept ability to create separation with soft hands. At 240 lbs, he'll need to pack on some more muscle and the Chiefs will likely work to evolve him as a blocker.

5.172 & 5.173. NT Ellis McCarthy, UCLA & ILB Mike Hull, Penn State

Time to body out this defense, right quick. McCarthy is a gigantic mountain of a man that will need significant work to get him into NFL shape. He can nonetheless be a force at 6'5" with ridiculous, long arms. Poe never comes out anyway, so at least he'll have a learning curve.

Hull is somebody I'm very excited about in the late rounds. Hull is an absolute drill sergeant on the field, with a contagious energy that elevates the play of the entire defense. He's also a very smart player, filling his gaps responsibly and hitting with serious power. He's not a Day One starter, but we don't need one of those -- we need a guy with starter upside, and Hull fits that to a T.

6.193. WR Austin Hill, Arizona

Hill was, at one point, one of the top threats in all of college football. A great combination of hands, athleticism, and route-running had him projected as a very good NFL receiver -- until he tore his ACL in 2013. Since then, he's spent the past year doing what he can to get his game going, with middling results.

The Chiefs can pretty much immediately insert Hill into the strength & conditioning program and eventually get him back to his previously awesome ability.

6.217. DE Daryl Waud, Western Ontario

I spent the day yesterday checking out some Canadian talents, and it turns out that Waud is pretty damn impressive, at 6'5", 290 lbs, with good athleticism and the frame to show off some powerful strength. The Chiefs like shopping north of the border, obviously.

7.233. K Kyle Brindza, Notre Dame

Cairo Santos does not inspire confidence. It's time for an upgrade, and Brindza is arguably my favorite kicker in the draft.

Direckshun
04-02-2015, 12:17 PM
QB: Smith, Daniel, Pryor vs. Murray
RB: Charles, Davis, Thomas, Gray
FB: Sherman

WR: Maclin, Smith, Avant, Wilson, Thomas, Hill
TE: Kelce, Kroft, Harris

LT: Fisher, Stephenson
LG: Grubbs, Duvarney-Tardif
C: Dismukes, Kush
RG: Fanaika, Fulton
RT: Allen, Stephenson

DE: DeVito, Howard, Waud
NT: Poe, McCarthy
DE: Bailey, Catapano

OLB: Hali, Ford
ILB: Mauga, Hull
ILB: Johnson, Johnson
OLB: Houston, Mauldin

CB: Smith, Johnson, Gaines, Fleming, Cooper
S: Abdullah, Parker, Branch, Commings, McCray

K: Brindza
P: Colquitt
LS: some guy

the Talking Can
04-02-2015, 12:33 PM
if there is really a 3rd round pick capable of starting for us at center, then no way in hell do i want ol in the first

CleveSteve
04-02-2015, 12:34 PM
It's interesting how much people's opinions can vary.

To me, Dismukes is one of the most overrated players in the draft. I think he's a pretty middling college center, and I have six guys ahead of him at the spot.

If I was looking to start a rookie at center I'd draft Erving at 18 every day and twice on Thursday before I'd put Dismukes in there at any round. Here's how I have them rated:

Rank Name School Pos Height Weight Round
1 Cameron Erving Florida State OT 6'5" 308 2
2 Andy Gallik Boston College C 6'2" 299 3
3 Max Garcia Florida C 6'5" 305 4
4 Dillon Day Miss State C 6'4" 305 4
5 Hroniss Grasu Oregon C 6'3" 297 5
6 B.J. Finney Kansas State C 6'4" 324 6
7 Reese Dismukes Auburn C 6'3" 295 7
8 Brandon VitabileNorthwestern C 6'2" 304 UDFA
9 David Andrews Georgia C 6'3" 294 UDFA
10 Shane McDermott Miami (Fla.) C 6'4" 302 UDFA

But that's JMO.

Direckshun
04-02-2015, 12:36 PM
I wanted Grasu with that pick, as I think he's better and a clear Dorsey pick, but I assume he'll be gone by that time.

Direckshun
04-02-2015, 12:36 PM
if there is really a 3rd round pick capable of starting for us at center, then no way in hell do i want ol in the first

Do you want a starter, or do you want a STARTER.

That's essentially the calculation being made.

jonzie04
04-02-2015, 12:43 PM
i just dont understand your infatuation of cam erving. i like the guy, i like me some fatties too. I took him in the second in one of my mock drafts several months ago. i still like him as an immediate interior lineman who could eventually play tackle. but he just flat out isn't as good as the other tackle prospects in this class. i think he's a 2nd to 3rd round type of player as a tackle, and i dont think any center is worth a first round pick.

CleveSteve
04-02-2015, 12:45 PM
I wanted Grasu with that pick, as I think he's better and a clear Dorsey pick, but I assume he'll be gone by that time.

Yeah it's looking that way that he'll be gone. He is definitely the most athletic of all the centers outside Erving. He's got very quick feet, at least initially to set up his block.

Direckshun
04-02-2015, 12:49 PM
I think Erving probably ends up playing center in the NFL. He could play tackle or guard somewhere eventually, but I think he's a center.

I believe in positional value as much as anybody, but at the end of the day, you've got to be pragmatic.

What will make the Chiefs better: Cam Erving, or Kevin Johnson. Not "a center" versus "a corner" on "a hypothetical NFL team." We have known roster realities and available talent to consider.

the Talking Can
04-02-2015, 12:51 PM
Do you want a starter, or do you want a STARTER.

That's essentially the calculation being made.

if it means getting a #1 CB or dupree...a 'starter' is fine

CleveSteve
04-02-2015, 12:52 PM
I think Erving probably ends up playing center in the NFL. He could play tackle or guard somewhere eventually, but I think he's a center.

I believe in positional value as much as anybody, but at the end of the day, you've got to be pragmatic.

What will make the Chiefs better: Cam Erving, or Kevin Johnson. Not "a center" versus "a corner" on "a hypothetical NFL team." We have known roster realities and available talent to consider.

Agreed!

People talk about reaching for a player of need, of drafting the best available player, etc... but that's thinking about the draft pick-by-pick. At the end of the (three) days it's about "how much have you improved your team?" You have to look at the collection of players you got and ask yourself "How much did my team improve? What weaknesses do I have that my opponents will try to exploit?"

If you just take BPA every pick and don't think about needs you'll end up drafting 5 damned running backs.

jonzie04
04-02-2015, 01:15 PM
center just isn't that important of a position in the end of the day... an elite center is going to do very little in improving a team. what combo of players would make the chiefs better?

Richard Sherman, and an average Center like Stefan Wisenski

or Maurkice pouncey, and an average corner like Brandon Carr?

how about

Joe Thomas, and an average guard like geoff schwartz

or

Marshal Yanda and an average tackle like eric fisher(ok maybe fisher isn't average)

Dez Bryant and an old Chris Myers

or Rodney Hudson, and Eddie Royal

Center is one of the least impactful positions in football, and having an elote center isn't going to win you jack.

the draft nevers ends up how its supposed to but the first round pick gives you the best chance possible of finding an elite player, and i don't want our best chance going on a center. i'd much rather try to find an elite tackle, cb, wr, te, really anything but center.

BigChiefFan
04-02-2015, 01:49 PM
Don't love it, but I appreciate the effort and I'm just glad to see some new football threads.

CleveSteve
04-02-2015, 01:53 PM
center just isn't that important of a position in the end of the day... an elite center is going to do very little in improving a team. what combo of players would make the chiefs better?

Center is one of the least impactful positions in football, and having an elote center isn't going to win you jack.

the draft nevers ends up how its supposed to but the first round pick gives you the best chance possible of finding an elite player, and i don't want our best chance going on a center. i'd much rather try to find an elite tackle, cb, wr, te, really anything but center.

Sorry, don't agree. Last year, the Browns started off really good (7-4), were in first place in their division, then had injuries on O and D and it all went to hell (and finished 7-9). But the most important injury was Alex Mack.

The Browns’ rushing offense dipped from 146.4 rushing yards per game with Mack to 90.5 without him.

Dante84
04-02-2015, 05:58 PM
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/pDxw_rjMRA8" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Dante84
04-02-2015, 06:43 PM
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/pDxw_rjMRA8" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

0:53 - Great read and tackle on the WR screen.

1:43 - Gets beat on a fly route to the endzone, can't keep up so he hold's the WR's jersey; luckily doesn't get flagged.

2:50 - Looks like shit trying to defend a punt return. Toub won't like that.

4:48 - CB Blitz... he gets to Winston and pulls up on the pump fake, instead of making a big hit. Good job forcing the early throw, though.

5:17 - Great coverage; follows up the PBU with at throat slash motion. Should have been 15 yards.

6:45 - Whiffs on an open field tackle of Winston, because he was trying to make a big hit. He instead gives up the first down. Very Bernard Pollard-esque.

6:55 - FUCKING DESTROYS the WR. Probably gets a flag for defenseless receiver in the NFL. Sometimes you need that aggression though. I liked it.

O.city
04-03-2015, 08:48 AM
He's really solid technique wise. I tend to lean towards Peters because of more physical upside, but he's got some offf field issues.

kccrow
04-05-2015, 03:48 PM
At least you don't have a center in round 1 in this edition. Food for thought... Andy Reid's starters in Philadelphia were 2 UDFAs (Hank Fraley, Jamaal Jackson) and a 6th Round pick (Jason Kelce) at center. He simply doesn't put that kind of priority on the center position.

I'm pretty well keyed in on Johnson as my favorite pick for the 1st round. Kid does most everything well.

RunKC
04-05-2015, 04:25 PM
I like Johnson a lot too. But with this regime I'm just seeing a fatty at 18 unfortunately.

buddha
04-05-2015, 04:42 PM
So, you wouldn't take Trae Waynes if he's there at 18?

Direckshun
04-05-2015, 05:26 PM
Waynes is likely a Top 10 pick.

el borracho
04-06-2015, 01:01 PM
Why are you mocking guys without measurables? If there is any trend to Dorsey's picks, it is measurables- size, speed, etc.

Direckshun
04-06-2015, 02:36 PM
I completely agree, and I absolutely do mock guys with impressive measurables 90% of the time.

Dorsey's drafts haven't been ALL measureables-obsessive, but they've been very close.

Oxford
04-08-2015, 02:15 PM
Anyone see the Chiefs trading down with someone later in the 1st? Maybe trade 1's and get an extra 3?

milkman
04-08-2015, 02:56 PM
Anyone see the Chiefs trading down with someone later in the 1st? Maybe trade 1's and get an extra 3?

The manner in which the Chiefs have handled this off season and free agency, I would expect them to trade up more than to trade down.

The Franchise
04-08-2015, 03:02 PM
The manner in which the Chiefs have handled this off season and free agency, I would expect them to trade up more than to trade down.

We've got the picks to do it.

DaneMcCloud
04-08-2015, 03:02 PM
Five Things to Know About Chiefs Center Eric Kush

http://www.kcchiefs.com/news/article-2/Five-Things-to-Know-About-Chiefs-Center-Eric-Kush/048146ef-3c85-4ddc-88db-7d9c1a7af0ee

The Chiefs aren't taking a center in the first three rounds

milkman
04-08-2015, 03:38 PM
Five Things to Know About Chiefs Center Eric Kush

http://www.kcchiefs.com/news/article-2/Five-Things-to-Know-About-Chiefs-Center-Eric-Kush/048146ef-3c85-4ddc-88db-7d9c1a7af0ee

The Chiefs aren't taking a center in the first three rounds

Yep, he's a kid that played two years at center in college, not to mention he's a hunter and a newly minted Royals fan.

Sure lock HoFer.

Chiefnj2
04-09-2015, 10:09 AM
Why are you mocking guys without measurables? If there is any trend to Dorsey's picks, it is measurables- size, speed, etc.

Dorsey's got some Al Davis in him.

Faddy Yomama
04-09-2015, 11:32 AM
Me and you both have Daryl Waud in the sixth round. Excellent choice.

Couch-Potato
04-09-2015, 09:54 PM
6:55 - ****ING DESTROYS the WR. Probably gets a flag for defenseless receiver in the NFL. Sometimes you need that aggression though. I liked it.

Love it!

Couch-Potato
04-09-2015, 09:56 PM
Really like a lot of the picks in this draft! A 1st round CB would really cap off our DB core, I think Smith is a perfect fit for Reid, Kroft and Hill are both on my radar as well.

Good work!

BullJunkandIron
04-10-2015, 08:45 PM
Might want to consider this guy. A tackling machine.

"Brown (6’2”, 319 pounds) had a breakout game last season for the Longhorns against the BYU Cougars, when he finished with 10 tackles and 2.5 sacks. He finished his junior season with 669 tackles and 6.5 sacks."

http://www.kcchiefs.com/news/article-2/2015-NFL-Mock-Draft-Roundup-320-Who-do-the-analysts-have-the-Chiefs-drafting/dc7ec870-318e-4e17-af11-6d792c81dcbd

Sandy Vagina
04-10-2015, 09:33 PM
I like enough of it to smile. rds 1 and 2 are good. Also would love Kroft in rd 4.

The rest is rather "meh"..

rd 1 - KJ (as is)
rd 2 - Devin Smith (solid)
rd 3 - rather Finney or Garcia, if you really want C there.
rd 3 - Mauldin looks so thin and poorly a fit.. rush LB not that big a need here. Maybe ILB here? Hicks, Snyder, or Taiwan Jones?
rd 4 - very nice.. Kroft is the right call.
rd 5 - Hull is interesting, but will get swallowed up by IOL. McCarthy is an asshole slackass... go Tyeler Davison or Joey Mbu.

.. and the rest, meh.

kccrow
04-10-2015, 10:00 PM
I really doubt Malcolm Brown will be on the board when KC picks.