Would you have rather got Mike Vick for QB?

[TribalElder]

Easy question

[TribalElder]

Watching the steelers replay and Vick throws a few long ass passes

[cosmo20002]

Would you rather be constipated or have diarrhea? Both shit-related problems.

[Hootie]

Vick belongs on the NFL field about as much as Alex Smith

[Rain Man]

No, thanks. I'm on the dogs' side.

[cosmo20002]

Would you rather be constipated or have diarrhea? Both shit-related problems.

This might actually be a good idea for a stand-alone thread/poll.

[Hammock Parties]

Michael Vick career record: 59-51-1
Playoff record: 2-4
Against 24+: 14-43-1

Alex Smith career record: 58-51-1
Playoff record: 1-2
Against 24+: 3-40-1

I'll go with the QB who has a better record and a better record against 24+ and more playoff wins.

[Reerun_KC]

ROFL. Chiefsplanet never disappointing....

[Pasta Little Brioni]

I would rather hire Vick as a dogsitter than watch Alex QB a game for this team.

[Hammock Parties]

The comparison is even funnier actually...

Seasons with 3000+ yards:

Alex: 3
Vick: 2

Seasons with 20+ TDs:

Alex: 1
Vick: 2

10+ win seasons:

Alex: 2
Vick: 1

[bdj23]

Would you rather be constipated or have diarrhea? Both shit-related problems.

Racist

[Hammock Parties]

We basically already have Vick, without the arm...except we paid through the fucking nose for him.

[Iconic]

ya

[Reerun_KC]

Chiefs fan always values other teams trash over our own trash.

[ThaVirus]

I'm officially to the point where I was during the Cassel years. I'd take any legitimate option over Smith.

Vick is dog shit, though. He's inaccurate and turnover-prone and still hasn't really learned how to pick apart a defense.

Still, the thought of him and Jamaal in the backfield at the same time would be a nightmare. JC might average over 6 YPC again. Vick also isn't afraid to throw downfield and his speed would suit this offensive line well.

[jonzie04]

I would rather hire Vick as a dogsitter than watch Alex QB a game for this team.

ROFLROFL

[Psyko Tek]

old broke dick Vick>>>> than Alex

[Why Not?]

I'd take Marcus Vick over Smith. Not kidding.

[New World Order]

Hasselbeck should have been our stop gap qb while we developed a young qb.

Because we are the Chiefs.

[stonedstooge]

At least Vick would be exciting to watch. Smith is boring as shit, even when he's on top of his game. Just horrid to watch

[Easy 6]

Sounds crazy, but... yes.

Just look at his play in the fourth last night, anyone see Smiff leading them down the field like that, taking big shots downfield or busting off a huge run?

I'm in the same boat now that I was with Cassel, just gimme somebody, ANYBODY else... Orton, Quinn, Detmer, Brister... I don't care, just gimme someone else right now.

[rabblerouser]

Hasselbeck should have been our stop gap qb while we developed a young qb.
That's exactly who Todd Haley wanted to bring in after 2010...

[notorious]

2 more 2nd round picks

Happy WR's

Shorter Shelf-Life


I am not seeing a downside to this.

[rico]

Ummmm....YEAH!!!

[Rain Man]

Hasselbeck should have been our stop gap qb while we developed a young qb.

Because we are the Chiefs.

He was a guy I wanted, too. Maybe I still want him.

[Eleazar]

Rather got? Is that like a pillowbitergot?

[Molitoth]

Sounds crazy, but... yes.

Just look at his play in the fourth last night, anyone see Smiff leading them down the field like that, taking big shots downfield or busting off a huge run?

I'm in the same boat now that I was with Cassel, just gimme somebody, ANYBODY else... Orton, Quinn, Detmer, Brister... I don't care, just gimme someone else right now.

This.

[BigMeatballDave]

I'd answer, but the pre-school level grammar in that question is grating on my nerves... :D

[TribalElder]

You grammar cops can suck it ROFL

I was drinking

[BigMeatballDave]

You grammar cops can suck it ROFL

I was drinkingLOL

It's funny. I hated English in school. My worst subject.

Now, most of my Pet Peeves have to do with improper grammar.

[loochy]

Is vick cheaper? If so, then hell yeah! If not, then there's no difference.