Cook vs Mahomes II

[Sully]

Both are on the board, who do you pick?

[Sully]

RB- More likely to be great, but is it drafting too high positionally?

QB- Boom or Bust guy, do you take the chance?


(Personally, I go with Mahomes. But Cook seems like a great pick)

[raybec 4]

I'd go Mahomes. There are some outstanding running backs to be had a little later and Cook's injury history scares me a little.

[staylor26]

This poll is going to be Mahomes in a landslide.

[Sully]

This poll is going to be Mahomes in a landslide.

Most likely.

[staylor26]

Most likely.

I will say that if we went with Cook, I'd still be happy as long as we take a QB on day 2. I know a lot of people are completely against RB in the 1st, but Cook would be fantastic in Reid's offense.

[raybec 4]

I will say that if we went with Cook, I'd still be happy as long as we take a QB on day 2. I know a lot of people are completely against RB in the 1st, but Cook would be fantastic in Reid's offense.

I agree with this. Either order is fine but they need a QBOTF and a back that can take some pressure off of our current starter. 35 yards in a playoff game isn't getting it done Spencer.

[Sandy Vagina]

Wouldn't be overjoyed with either, but would go with the QB, and hope for the best.

[Sully]

Wouldn't be overjoyed with either, but would go with the QB, and hope for the best.

Frankly, I'm just crowd sourcing (after the fact) dilemmas that come up while I'm playing around with Fanspeak.

[OldSchool]

I know Cook is the sure thing so I'd go with him over Mahomes simply because I know one will be successful in Reid's system while the other is a major wildcard and likely bust.

[Bowser]

Mahomes in round 1, Alvin Kamara in round 2

[staylor26]

Mahomes in round 1, Alvin Kamara in round 2

JIMP

[raybec 4]

Mahomes in round 1, Alvin Kamara in round 2

Our Offense would be instantly better, by a lot.

[MahiMike]

I'm off the Mahomes wagon after some scouts evaluations. Give me Jamaal 2.0

[Sorter]

Would prefer Mixon.

[Hog's Gone Fishin]

Would prefer Mixon.

Bingo, he has the quick twitch reflex. I've seen it on video.

[Sorter]

Bingo, he has the quick twitch reflex. I've seen it on video.

http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/gyo.gif

[staylor26]

Would prefer Mixon.

Well yea, but we're not going to do that two drafts in a row. Wish we would though.

[kccrow]

Who the fuck would ever take a RB over a potential franchise QB? Not this guy. I'll take a back in a later round and be just as happy.

[staylor26]

Just to clarify, I was talking about Cook vs. Mixon

[Black Bob]

Cook

Mahommes should be a day three pick.