Alex Smith Top 25 QB All Time?

[Titty Meat]

https://twitter.com/ih8bobby/status/1153136732155441153?s=09


Haha I've smoked alot of weed and never thought this!

[TLO]

To the romper room. Dilly Dilly!

[MAHOMO 4 LIFE!]

PAChiefs made this didn’t he

[raidersnumber1]

once this Mahomes hoopla is over, people will look back at Alex Smith as the best Chiefs QB of all time.

[TLO]

I wonder where Geno Smith ranks? :hmmm:

Also - I almost quoted the idiot above me. But then realized he'll be downvoted into oblivion so thought twice about it. O suggest nobody else quote him either and just give him the ol thumbs down.

[Hammock Parties]

He's not even top 25 in the last 25 years, let alone all time.

Jesus fuck.

[Titty Meat]

To the romper room. Dilly Dilly!

Thread will do numbers wherever it goes

[chinaski]

once this Mahomes hoopla is over, people will look back at Alex Smith as the best Chiefs QB of all time.

Get the fuck off this board. Seriously.

[New World Order]

I'd take Randall Cunningham, Mcnabb, Flaccid, Eli, Gannon, Mcnair, Brunell, Foles over Smith

[Pablo]

Trent Green make the top 15?

[Bump]

Alex is top 25 for the Chiefs

[Titty Meat]

25 most recent that are better:

Brady
Peyton
Eli
Rivers
Palmer
Vick
Warner
Carr
Luck
Mahomes
Stafford
Culpepper
Cutler maybe
Bulger
McNair
Brad Johnson
Watson
Wentz
Foles maybe
Roethlisberger
Bledsoe
Wilson


Feel free to add on

[carcosa]

I feel like I'm losing my mind

[Hammock Parties]

Fuck, in 2016 he wasn't even one of the top 25 QBS in the league.

FUCK!!

[notorious]

https://img.buzzfeed.com/buzzfeed-static/static/2014-09/23/18/enhanced/webdr11/anigif_enhanced-buzz-25912-1411510210-20.gif

[RealSNR]

I saw the B/R logo at the bottom. What retard at Drinking Bleach Report thought up this marvelous list?

Honestly, Alex Smith at 25 is fucking ridiculous, but what might be even worse is fucking Namath at 7.

[RunKC]

Rivers being on that list is almost as embarrassing as Alex. What the hell has that guy done with several talented teams in his career?

Rivers might be the most overrated QB ever

[Mahomes_Is_God]

I'd take Randall Cunningham, Mcnabb, Flaccid, Eli, Gannon, Mcnair, Brunell, Foles over Smith

**** no, that's just crazy talk.

[Third Eye]

I saw the B/R logo at the bottom. What retard at Drinking Bleach Report thought up this marvelous list?

Honestly, Alex Smith at 25 is fucking ridiculous, but what might be even worse is fucking Namath at 7.

Nobody. It’s pretty obviously fake. Just a troll job to get all the snowflakes worked up. Seems to be working in that regard.

[BigCatDaddy]

He wasn't top 25 most years he played.

[New World Order]

**** no, that's just crazy talk.

You wouldn't take Eli over Alex?

Flacco has Alexian seasonal numbers but he led his team to one hell of a SB run.

[Ming the Merciless]

Rivers being on that list is almost as embarrassing as Alex. What the hell has that guy done with several talented teams in his career?

Rivers might be the most overrated QB ever

I'd still pick.him.over Alex in a draft 100 times out of 100

[Naptown Chief]

I heard Mr Smith was a great guy and the children love him!

[Rain Man]

And Elway's on it too? That's hilarious.

[Rain Man]

There's also no Otto Graham and no Sammy Baugh on the list. Was this some sort of middle school project or something?

[Rasputin]

Mark Dirtysanchez has won more playoff games than Alec Smith.

[rabblerouser]

once this Mahomes hoopla is over, people will look back at Alex Smith as the best Chiefs QB of all time.

When did they start allowing internet access to the mentally challenged locked up in the nuthouses?

[New World Order]

And Elway's on it too? That's hilarious.

Want to read a funny joke?

Who put up a horrid statline of 12-23 133 yards and 1 int in the SB vs GB?

John Elway

[Mile High Mania]

Aikman, Namath, Bradshaw, Warner, Kelly Romo, Bledsoe, Griese, Palmer, Simms, Smith all ranked too high.

[TEX]

Aikman, Namath, Bradshaw, Warner, Kelly Romo, Bledsoe, Griese, Palmer, Simms, Smith all ranked too high.

ROFL
But not Elway? Of COURSE not! :rolleyes:

[Dayze]

Want to read a funny joke?

Who put up a horrid statline of 12-23 133 yards and 1 int in the SB vs GB?

John Elway

THIS ONE's......FOR JOHN!

[jjchieffan]

That whole list is messed up. Manning above Montana and Johnny U??? Aikman at 6?? Aikman is no closer to 6 than Smith is to 25. Palmer is another that shouldn't make the top 25.

[SuperBowl4]

Matt Cassel getting looked over again

[TEX]

Matt Cassel getting looked over again

ROFL

[FlaChief58]

Shit like this is why you shouldn't smoke crack

[Munson]

If you made a list of top 25 "check down" QBs of all time, Alex Smith would definitely be on that list.

[scho63]

We've got Patrick Mahomes and you start a new Alex Smith thread?

Are you on crack??? :$2500:

[Mile High Mania]

ROFL
But not Elway? Of COURSE not! :rolleyes:

There aren't a lot of people outside of those on this board that view Elway as a mid rung QB. It's fun reading about it though.

[Sorce]

Where is Tyler fucking Palko on that list?

[Rain Man]

Where is Tyler fucking Palko on that list?

He should be just above Elway. No?


Trivia for the day:

Tyler Palko had a QB rating above 80 in 50 percent of his NFL seasons.
John Elway had a QB rating above 80 in 44 percent of his NFL seasons.

[SAUTO]

In compensation?

I'd bet top 10
1.1
2 2s
3 and fuller

Couple Hundred million in salary.

[RollChiefsRoll]

I'd take Randall Cunningham, Mcnabb, Flaccid, Eli, Gannon, Mcnair, Brunell, Foles over Smith

Mark Brunell over Alex Smith? You shittin' me?

[carcosa]

Mark Brunell over Alex Smith? You shittin' me?

Brunell has more AFC Championship Game appearances

[Kiimo]

Nobody. It’s pretty obviously fake. Just a troll job to get all the snowflakes worked up. Seems to be working in that regard.

I'm glad someone else realized this.

The guy is bragging about it.


https://www.crossingbroad.com/2019/07/some-guy-made-a-fake-top-25-quarterback-list-that-went-viral.html


<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="et" dir="ltr">I got Alex Smith trending in the US LMAAOAOAOAOA</p>&mdash; Owen ❼ (@Se7enRings) <a href="https://twitter.com/Se7enRings/status/1153137698472960000?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">July 22, 2019</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

[Reerun_KC]

Alex Smith. ROFL

[New World Order]

Mark Brunell over Alex Smith? You shittin' me?

More playoff wins and statistically led the league in passing yards in 96.

He took an expansion team to the AFC title game, beating Jim Kelly and John Elway along the way.

[big nasty kcnut]

You may bash Alex but he did great while he was here and set everything up nicely for pat to get us a super bowl. Plus he prove what a fraud kapernick was.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

ABSOLUTELY MAN!!!!
( sound of glass pipe firing up while lamb bleats in the background from its current ass fucking )

[Mile High Mania]

More playoff wins and statistically led the league in passing yards in 96.

He took an expansion team to the AFC title game, beating Jim Kelly and John Elway along the way.

Thanks to Michael Dean Perry...

[OrtonsPiercedTaint]

Alex was the best he could possible be. It was probably exhausting & just not enough

[New World Order]

Thanks to Michael Dean Perry...

Denver had a top 5 d and Jax put 30 on them in Denver.

[Mile High Mania]

Denver had a top 5 d and Jax put 30 on them in Denver.

Tough loss... Denver totally took them for granted and Means went off. Denver's D forces a critical punt late in the 3rd and MDP's fat a$$ can't get off the field, gets the penalty and they get a first down and proceed to run another 10 plays before getting a FG. Crazy. Totally overlooked those guys.

[New World Order]

There aren't a lot of people outside of those on this board that view Elway as a mid rung QB. It's fun reading about it though.

Where would you place him?

[Rain Man]

A small sample of Elway overrated articles. There are about 55,000 more of them, but I won't link them all.

http://jessethesportswriter.blogspot.com/2014/09/john-elway-sucks.html - This is a good article. I highly recommend you read this article if you in any way think that John Elway was a decent quarterback.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/6p1pwo/why_is_john_elway_so_overrated/

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/brgv7p/john_elway_is_one_of_the_most_overrated_qbs_of/

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/778095-john-elway-why-hes-the-most-overrated-athlete-of-all-time

https://www.sportsblog.com/sportatistics/overrated-the-real-john-elway-career/

https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=714861

https://www.ign.com/boards/threads/im-sorry-but-john-elway-is-extremely-overrated.103052579/

[NWTF]

If you made a list of top 25 "check down" QBs of all time, Alex Smith would definitely be on that list.

He played it safe too much for me. His numbers probably do look pretty good looking at after the fact, but for those who actually watched him play, ROFL at Top 25. Not even close. Guys that take the check down on 3rd and 8 or simply throw it away with the game on the line because their wasnt an easy opening shouldnt be rewarded because their numbers werent that bad when looking at the Box Score. I hate QBs like that. Guys that go through the motions and take what the defense gives them with the game on the line and everyone in the whole stadium knows the game is on the line. Guys that have already accepted a loss and are simply playing it out and protecting their stat line. Smith was a fine QB to hold the fort till reinforcements (Mahomes) arrived, but Top 25 talk is laughable.

[MarkDavis'Haircut]

There's also no Otto Graham and no Sammy Baugh on the list. Was this some sort of middle school project or something?

Probably no Benny Friedman either.

Worthless list.

[MarkDavis'Haircut]

More playoff wins and statistically led the league in passing yards in 96.

He took an expansion team to the AFC title game, beating Jim Kelly and John Elway along the way.

Tom Coughlin magic, baby!

[MarkDavis'Haircut]

A small sample of Elway overrated articles. There are about 55,000 more of them, but I won't link them all.

http://jessethesportswriter.blogspot.com/2014/09/john-elway-sucks.html - This is a good article. I highly recommend you read this article if you in any way think that John Elway was a decent quarterback.

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/6p1pwo/why_is_john_elway_so_overrated/

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/brgv7p/john_elway_is_one_of_the_most_overrated_qbs_of/

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/778095-john-elway-why-hes-the-most-overrated-athlete-of-all-time

https://www.sportsblog.com/sportatistics/overrated-the-real-john-elway-career/

https://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=714861

https://www.ign.com/boards/threads/im-sorry-but-john-elway-is-extremely-overrated.103052579/

Thank you for the list. Elway is so overrated.

[ChiefBlueCFC]

Grbac has to be in consideration as well, yes?

[el borracho]

25th all time?- No
About 25th each season, maybe.

[007]

2-5 in the playoffs. Um no. LMAO