Originally Posted by 49er1973 (Post 10166617)

Since some are dissatisfied with AS11's play who do you think they should start at QB after the bye.

Originally Posted by 49er1973 (Post 10166617)

Since some are dissatisfied with AS11's play who do you think they should start at QB after the bye.

Originally Posted by Nightfyre (Post 10166624)

49er fans are no longer welcome to discuss Alex Smith with us. Good bye.

Originally Posted by 49er1973 (Post 10166635)

Why may I ask?

Originally Posted by Nightfyre (Post 10166646)

Probably because we're sick of you all coming in here like you know something we don't about Alex Smith. Probably because the 9ers swindled the Chiefs out of two perfectly good draft picks for a mediocre game manager. Probably because it is overbearing when 49er fans try to convince us what a great deal we got. Probably because you asked stupid rhetorical questions like "who would you start instead next week." Probably because Jason Campbell would have been just as good for half the money and none of the draft picks. :shake:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166669)

The 9ers swindled us, yet they have a worse passing offense than we do

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166669)

The 9ers swindled us, yet they have a worse passing offense than we do

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10166682)

Disagree completely.

Yards per completion:

Kaepernick #2
Smith #33

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166669)

The 9ers swindled us, yet they have a worse passing offense than we do

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166686)

I'm glad you disagree.

Literally everything you've thought has been wrong, so I must be doing something right.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10166690)

Do you really think Alex Smith is good? Or even average?

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166696)

Do you know what an average nfl qb looks like?

Originally Posted by 49er1973 (Post 10166659)

I would say swindled would be putting it pretty strong.
And I for one did not want Smith to leave.
But I'm sorry if I offended anyone and will delete this account.
Thank you for your time

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10166690)

Do you really think Alex Smith is good? Or even average?

Originally Posted by Brock (Post 10166721)

Surrounded by talent. LMAO that's.......great.....

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166732)

Yeah.

Because pioli said that about cassel it can never be true about any other qb, right?

Matt Ryan doesn't need his all pro wrs, tes. Brady can do it without welker and gronk. Big Ben don't need no mike Wallace.


Apparently qbs league wide can win games all on their own throwing to scrubs.

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166732)

Yeah.

Because pioli said that about cassel it can never be true about any other qb, right?

Matt Ryan doesn't need his all pro wrs, tes. Brady can do it without welker and gronk. Big Ben don't need no mike Wallace.


Apparently qbs league wide can win games all on their own throwing to scrubs.

Originally Posted by PGM (Post 10166013)

Guess we should win every game by 20 instead of 12!

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 10166696)

Do you know what an average nfl qb looks like?

Originally Posted by aturnis (Post 10166807)

Maybe the defense should just stay on the field in pace of the offense!

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy (Post 10166706)

If only the rest of the 9er douche bags would learn from this one.

Originally Posted by NinerDoug (Post 10167763)

If wishes were horses, then beggars would ride.

If I were you, I would wish for something better, and attainable, like an AFC Championship (followed by a loss to the Niners in the Superbowl, of course.)

<b> Your only path to getting rid of the Niner fans around here is if Alex starts losing and gets benched. You don't want that, do you?</b>

Having us Niners fans around is simply the price you pay for victory. :)

Originally Posted by BossChief (Post 10167773)

Dwayne Bowe is a stud. Andy and John know this and are paying him accordingly.

Avery had 800 yards last year.

Charles is a top 3 RB.

We have talent.

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace (Post 10146640)

REALLY? So alex smith who is leading the BEST team leads in deep completions? SWWWEEEEET

Wait. hold up, you said that the LEADERS, now its 6 of 8? You are confusing me dude. make up which side you want to be on.

Well, not necessarily a coincidence. Usually the best qbs tend to have the best talent around them.

You know, Welker, Demariyus, Decker, Julius Thomas,

Jordy Nelson, James Jones, Boykin, Randall Cobb

Kenny stills, Marques Colston, Darren sproles, some dude named Jimmy Graham

Vernon Davis, Anquan Boldin, Kyle Williams.

Aj Green Eifert, Gresham, Sanu, Marvin Jones.

Then there is this group of FANTASTIC DEEP THREATS.

Anthony Fasano, Donnie Avery, Dwayne Bowe, Midget McCluster.

Are you starting to see the DIFFERENCE here?



Yeah, and without Pitta, and Boldin, how is that going for them this year?

Joe Flacco is a franchise qb. His performance in the playoffs showed everyone. He is elite. Why are his numbers no where near what they were?

Boldin was worth getting rid of for a measly 6th round pick.

Pitta wasn't known as a super star tight end.

Why is Joe struggling?

Why is tom brady struggling. Tom Brady is the end all be all.

???? Great qbs, carry franchises.

Originally Posted by New World Order (Post 10167798)

Stop saying Alex Smith "leads." Our defense scored more points than the offense did against Buffalo for god's sake.

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace (Post 10167911)

So, Alex Smith is not a LEADER?

is that where this is going now?

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10167916)

The offense is poor, and Alex is a big reason why.

No doubt about it.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10167916)

The offense is poor, and Alex is a big reason why.

No doubt about it.

Originally Posted by NinerDoug (Post 10167939)

Having had that same offense for a season and a half, I completely understand where you are coming from.

Kind of like driving a VW. Not exciting, but at least it gets you where you want to go. (For me, having been taking the bus or even walking for the previous 8 seasons, I was pretty happy with the VW.)

Now, having a Porsche, of course, I enjoy it much more that the VW. I understand your envy of the Porsche, but hey, we can't all drive sports cars. Keep working and maybe you can have a Porsche someday too, or even convert your existing VW into a Porsche.

For the time being, try being happy you are not on the bus or walking.

Originally Posted by ptlyon (Post 10168011)

WHAT???

Originally Posted by NinerDoug (Post 10167939)

Having had that same offense for a season and a half, I completely understand where you are coming from.

Kind of like driving a VW. Not exciting, but at least it gets you where you want to go. (For me, having been taking the bus or even walking for the previous 8 seasons, I was pretty happy with the VW.)

Now, having a Porsche, of course, I enjoy it much more that the VW. I understand your envy of the Porsche, but hey, we can't all drive sports cars. Keep working and maybe you can have a Porsche someday too, or even convert your existing VW into a Porsche.

For the time being, try being happy you are not on the bus or walking.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10168873)

Matt Cassel > Alex Smith

http://i.imgur.com/JuXFjyG.gif

Originally Posted by keg in kc (Post 10168890)

Aw, how cute, has a Fiat and thinks it's a Porsche.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10168873)

Matt Cassel > Alex Smith

http://i.imgur.com/JuXFjyG.gif

Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS (Post 10168904)

Meh, He had single coverage on the seam route for a possible TD, against an LB!

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10168873)

Matt Cassel > Alex Smith

http://i.imgur.com/JuXFjyG.gif

Originally Posted by Tuckdaddy (Post 10168984)

Alex is not great but this is just stupid. Matt is crap.

Originally Posted by Mavericks Ace (Post 10167911)

Yeah, thank god Alex Smith didn't throw an absolute seed to Dexter McCluster who was wide open, and would have scored.

Sheesh.

Then what?

So, Alex Smith is not a LEADER?

is that where this is going now?

Originally Posted by keg in kc (Post 10168890)

Aw, how cute, has a Fiat and thinks it's a Porsche.

Originally Posted by NinerDoug (Post 10167939)

Having had that same offense for a season and a half, I completely understand where you are coming from.

Kind of like driving a VW. Not exciting, but at least it gets you where you want to go. (For me, having been taking the bus or even walking for the previous 8 seasons, I was pretty happy with the VW.)

Now, having a Porsche, of course, I enjoy it much more that the VW. I understand your envy of the Porsche, but hey, we can't all drive sports cars. Keep working and maybe you can have a Porsche someday too, or even convert your existing VW into a Porsche.

For the time being, try being happy you are not on the bus or walking.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10168986)

2010 Matt Cassel > Alex

Originally Posted by Messier (Post 10169302)

Alex>2011, 2012 Matt Cassel

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10169305)

Better than bad does not equal good.

It's pretty sad because Alex is not even meeting my low expectations.

Originally Posted by KCDC (Post 10168899)

We gave up a second for Cassel and now two seconds for Cassel without the turnovers.

Originally Posted by AussieChiefsFan (Post 10169310)

He probably was at the beginning of the season.

What are your low expectations and what are your high expectations for Alex.

I'm actually wondering.

Originally Posted by NinerDoug (Post 10167939)

Having had that same offense for a season and a half, I completely understand where you are coming from.

Kind of like driving a VW. Not exciting, but at least it gets you where you want to go. (For me, having been taking the bus or even walking for the previous 8 seasons, I was pretty happy with the VW.)

Now, having a Porsche, of course, I enjoy it much more that the VW. I understand your envy of the Porsche, but hey, we can't all drive sports cars. Keep working and maybe you can have a Porsche someday too, or even convert your existing VW into a Porsche.

For the time being, try being happy you are not on the bus or walking.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10169305)

Better than bad does not equal good.

It's pretty sad because Alex is not even meeting my low expectations.

Originally Posted by Messier (Post 10169398)

I didn't say that it did. I do think you, and your sidekicks are undervaluing Smith, based on stats. And I know that sounds absurd to you, because you don't scratch your ass unless PFF says it's a good idea.

Smith is a quality veteran starting QB. I can't think of anyone (in the real world) that would say he isn't. He's flawed, sure, He's the opposite of a Romo type gunslinger. Cautious to a fault. But i do absolutely believe that any other QB that the Chiefs could've acquired in the off-season would have cost the Chiefs games, plural, This season.

I admit Geno Smith is playing better than I thought he would, and could become good in a few years, but like you said, 9-0 doesn't happen very often, and you must take advantage while its here, and I do feel Geno would squander that record by costing a game, possibly in the playoffs.

Anyway,continue, but I know Smith is helping them win, and I'm confident in saying that if any other QB that was available is here instead, the Chiefs aren't 9-0.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10168873)

Matt Cassel > Alex Smith

Originally Posted by aturnis (Post 10169434)

So full of fail.

Alex has not been a quality starting vet QB this season. He hasn't thrown a TD in 5 of 9 games this season. Has been atrocious on third down, and can't utilize his weapons.

Also, Jason Campbell would be9-0 with this defense.

Originally Posted by aturnis (Post 10169434)

So full of fail.

Alex has not been a quality starting vet QB this season. He hasn't thrown a TD in 5 of 9 games this season. Has been atrocious on third down, and can't utilize his weapons.

Also, Jason Campbell would be9-0 with this defense.

Originally Posted by ChiefRocka (Post 10169596)

I'm calling a 300+ yard passing day for Sir Alex.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10169659)

The 4th of his career.

A red letter day.

Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS (Post 10169741)

RGIII threw for more yards than the Vikings and lost.

Say it with me...

"Alex is the winningest QB in the league over the last 3 seasons."

Originally Posted by hometeam (Post 10169746)

I didn't know wins was an individual stat.

Guess the other 52 guys, coaches, front office personal had nothing to do with any of that.

Originally Posted by hometeam (Post 10169746)

I didn't know wins was an individual stat.

Guess the other 52 guys, coaches, front office personal had nothing to do with any of that.

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy (Post 10169753)

Sherman. The winningest FB in the NFL.

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy (Post 10169753)

Sherman. The winningest FB in the NFL.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10169772)

QB is the most important position on the field unless that means giving credit to Alex Smith for winning.


Got it.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10169772)

QB is the most important position on the field unless that means giving credit to Alex Smith for winning.


Got it.

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy (Post 10169782)

Sure, but let's not pretend if he was with Jacksonville the last few years he would be 26-5 or whatever.

Originally Posted by JENKINSWINS (Post 10169765)

Not saying he's the only reason for the wins but he's been part of 2 huge turn arounds for 2 different NFL franchises. You can't say that about any other player on the team.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10169659)

The 4th of his career.

A red letter day.

Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead (Post 10169659)

The 4th of his career.

A red letter day.

Originally Posted by Mr. Plow (Post 10169830)

Has he really only thrown for 300+ yards 3 times in his career? I don't think I believe that.

Originally Posted by Mr. Plow (Post 10169830)

Has he really only thrown for 300+ yards 3 times in his career? I don't think I believe that.

Originally Posted by ChiefRocka (Post 10169596)

Cant wait to see what happens next Monday night. I think Andy and Alex are gonna turn heads (in a good way). We've definitely been holding back on Offense and Defense the past couple weeks. I'm calling a 300+ yard passing day for Sir Alex.