it's hilarious to me that people are going to try and tell me a guy from the 1960s in a TOTALLY DIFFERENT GAME is better than a guy who has BASICALLY every QB record and a guy who literally has won his division like 15 times out of 17

ok

yeah

that's super logical

Using that logic Derek Jeter is the greatest Yankee of all time over Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio etc.

Red Grange >>> Adrian Peterson

if you took 1940's Red Grange and put him in today's NFL he'd be ... the water boy?

You are welcome.

Tis the season to be jolly.

Also give me Elway over Manning any day of the week.

uhm, no

not at all

wtf

...

lmfao

you need to explain this one lolololol

Derek Jeter has worse numbers than all of those guys.

You want to compare Peyton's #'s to Unitas'?

wtf

god this board is so DUMB

Man, remember ****ing Adrian Peterson.

We'll probably never see him score a TD ever again.

Sad.

Draft a QB.

at least you can ****ing argue that one

...

though

you'd still be wrong

but at least, AT LEAST, this one is debatable

Elway vs. Manning is a real debate.

Peterson ranked one spot ahead of Alex at 22 in total qbr this year . Man, our qb sucks.

ok fine

it sure is

Manning vs. Unitas is not a real debate. It's ****ing stupid.

Haven't read this thread yet but will I am.

Daniels was ****ing hot ggarbagge today. Reid's game plane was a shit fest. Gonna wreck the Reid apologists tomorrow when I have some time.

Reid smith and daniels are all ****ing losers.

Romo is #1, Russell Wilson is#12

Romo superior to Wilson.

I don't think that many people disagree with you any more.

I've been a Romo fan since day 1

would not take him over Wilson

but he's in my top 5, over Drew Brees, no doubt