How many years of experience does Smith have?

Only the real stat matters.

Smith - L
Winston - W

Not sure why you keep posting this. Using these specific QB measures, Alex had a slightly better day than Jameis.

But hey, lets not look at the record column....you know, the stat you have been preaching is the only important thing.

And also, lets not look at the defense each QB was playing.

It's irrelevant, if discussing current QBs. This isn't about career trajectory.. which even much younger in age, can fall off a cliff.

Just because I don't suffer from delusions of Alex Smith grandeur doesn't mean I'm miserable. I know what he is and react accordingly. When he plays above his limitations I'm pleasantly surprised, and when he doesn't, like yesterday against the shit awful Bucs, I don't dive into excuse mode for him.

Yeah, all those amazing advanced metrics and he still can't mount a comeback win against a 4 win team, so who gives a ****.

This shit you're selling is Dick Vermeil logic - "Yeah, their running back had 172 yards rushing against us, but if you take out the 79 yarder and the 48 yarder, and we did a pretty good job against him!"

Regression? He was never that good to begin with.

You guys and your freaking stats. Smith is an average QB who is never going to carry the team on his back and fail if he is the focal point. Why is it so hard to see for you guys? He sucks and you are not winning anything as long as he is your QB.

Smith is averaging 1 touchdown a game. That is ****ing pathetic.

I'd like to call Hunt and tell him to take charge and get an offensive coordinator not to mention clock manager in there to help walrus boy do a better job. That would make a much bigger difference than changing personnel. Your "off season" solution is a sad old song to those of us who've followed this team for decades...

Most people don't have a problem seeing that besides this reerun Tigeruppercut.

Let's start another thread where everyone can rehash the same arguments.

You might be right, they may not change a thing, and they might...

But I'm not losing sleep over it cause its out of my hands.

Most people, including you, gave up on this team last year at 1-5.

Stick to your video games sweetheart. The overuse of reerun in your handful of posts over the last day has gotten very old.

Only an Alex Smith fan would says it's irrelevant.

I've always liked Alex Smith, but I'm going to have to side with the Smith critics on this one. Smith may not have been THE problem, but he sure as hell had a chance to be part of the solution, and he blew it with the pick in the end zone.

This goes back to the argument people make about Smith not being able to step up and carry the team in crucial situations. He failed at that yesterday.