Originally Posted by Sure-Oz (Post 12163198)

I just don't think he holds up like that...plus his RV was there...pretty sure he was beaten into telling the saviors where Rick and Co were heading. I'm thinking it's Abe or Daryl

Originally Posted by Dunit35 (Post 12163209)

My buddy said you could hear Maggie yelling "Glenn" when the beat down occurred. Anybody hear that?

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 12163263)

There would have been nothing wrong with us seeing who got smashed and the aftermath.

The real cliffhanger would have been the group not knowing WTF they can/are going to do about Negan.

Negan won't take out a prime contributor to his cause, he will take out the person who is the weakest.........and we all know who that is.

Originally Posted by Sandy Cheeks (Post 12163297)

This makes the most sense. I can't think of too many characters that wouldn't break the rule of instant retaliation.. therefore Carl's other eye removed.

If it were Maggie, half of them would instantly retaliate.. especially Glenn. Same goes for Sasha (Abe).. the kid (Rick).. Mishone (Rick).. Glenn (Maggie)... Rosita (Abe) .. doubt Eugene would absorb multiple hits..

I'm disgusted that Rick didn't do everything he could to fall on the sword. As a leader, he should have. Instead.. a terrified, quivering worm. Too bad Shane didn't survive that encounter instead.

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 12163263)

There would have been nothing wrong with us seeing who got smashed and the aftermath.

The real cliffhanger would have been the group not knowing WTF they can/are going to do about Negan.

Negan won't take out a prime contributor to his cause, he will take out the person who is the weakest.........and we all know who that is.

Originally Posted by Sandy Cheeks (Post 12163407)

I'm going to kill every last one of them, and call it a day.

Keeping them alive is lame.

Originally Posted by KC_Lee (Post 12163419)

I had the same thought. Jesus takes over for Daryl as Rick's right hand man.

Not to look to much into a reaction but the following happened during Talking Dead last night. The question was asked "Will get to see a Daryl shower scene next season?". The camera focused on Norman Redus and his reaction appeared, at least to me, was one of confusion.

He looked towards Scott Gimple and Robert Kirkman's direction and looked liked, again at least for me, he did not know what to say. Take it with a grain of salt but I think Norman tipped his hand.

Originally Posted by Fire Me Boy! (Post 12163744)

Saw that earlier. This makes me think they have no idea what they're doing. They did this so they could check the pulse. That's bullshit.

Originally Posted by smellypitts (Post 12163778)

did you not notice where they said everyone was there during that seen,even while off camera,in their places still acting out

Originally Posted by Sure-Oz (Post 12163880)

Oh absolutely... They still could've shown the death or who got it and we all would wonder next season how they get out of it.

Originally Posted by DanBecky (Post 12164061)

I think Rick was like that bc he felt he let his whole group down. They are basically in a no win situation. I mean, what are they gonna do in that scenario? Stripped of weapons, surrounded by all of Neegan's men. He thought it was the end for all them. And after what they've been through, they always made it out. But you could see on his face that he was basically defeated, that their luck had finally run out.

Originally Posted by smellypitts (Post 12164598)

Except it hasn't because it's tv and they only lose one. If It Really Happened, they'd all be dead.
Seriously....you just killed one third of my dumb followers..I guess I'll let you live. ..yeah,sure?

Originally Posted by KC_Lee (Post 12166072)

Not specifically but given Daryl's position relative to Dwight when he got shot and where all the blood was on Daryl it's reasonable to assume it was his left arm.

Daryl's left hand was completely bloody and when Dwight surprised Daryl a shot to that arm would be easiest and the least fatal.