Originally Posted by banyon

William Bartee = 82 :shake:

Carlos Hall = Jared Allen :shake:

Kendrell Bell > Derrick Johnson :shake:

Originally Posted by Lzen

Oh and I almost forgot

Tynes is too low.

BTW banyon, you do realize they they rated Bartee an 82 as a FS, not a CB. Right?

Also of note is that they rated Brodie Croyle's throwing power and accuracy pretty high:
THP - 90
THA - 85
He just needs experience to raise that awareness:
AWR - 67

Originally Posted by htismaqe

Bell is a former DRoY, Johnson is a 2nd-year player from a shitty defense.

Alot of what goes into Madden ratings is based on past performance, not current performance, athleticism, or potential.

Originally Posted by tk13

Bartee always has good ratings in Madden because he has all the physical skills, can tackle, and there's only one category for "awareness" to help bring your overall number down.

Originally Posted by banyon

Surely you meant to apply that logic solely to the Johnson/Bell comparison.

If based on past performance also, then Bartee's career 0 INT's should knock him down a peg or two. Also, Allen had good numbers that should be better than Hall's.