AP blew out his ACL DEC 24th...has a RB ever returned from an ACL injury that quickly and followed it up with a season such as his...?

Nobody knows how bad Peyton's neck was but Peyton. He has had a season much better than expected...but what AP has done in less than a year is almost sickening.

Peyton Manning although it could go either way

240 attempts, 1220 yards, 4 touchdowns. Great to have him back but he's not AP. Team MVP though... since there's so much competition for that.

No Jamaal Charles option?

No, because he's not in the same company as those two... and I didn't feel the need to skew voting with a homer option. JC has no shot. See post #18.

This. I ****ing hate the forehead, but the NFL slobbers all over that family.:banghead:

I can see how that would skew the poll, but disagree that he's not in the same company.

POLL FAIL! :)

This and completely this. Hasn't even been a year. That was an incredibly quick recovery to be dominating like he is.

That's because they're really good heh.

My wording may have been off but my meaning is he's not in AP's range stat wise this season. He's great no doubt. He'd probably have a good shot most years.

I did consider including Brady Quinn as a "Gaz" option but a bunch of numbnuts would vote for him... hence poll skewed. I'm actually interested in an honest vote heh.

AD

Adrian Peterson might break that record. He's a ****ing beast, you could make arguments for either one but AD might do something Legendary.

AP > PM

I'm at the airport, and there's a guy at my gate wearing a brand new #58 Broncos jersey with the name "Manning" on the back. I'll try to get a picture, but he's facing me so I can't get the back.

Manning. ACL injuries are no longer the career threatening injury the used to be. Manning is back from missing a year and with a completely different team. He was also cut by his previous team.