The dude receives ridiculous amounts of criticism meanwhile other QBs can make those mistakes and have a worse record without similar consequence.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CxQA2znHiDo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1H--0rZ0Dio

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-gameda...ter-Chiefs-win - Deion Sanders

Easily the most underrated and under appreciated QB in the league. I'm not going back to the Cassel/Pioli days, I'm sticking with Reid/Smitty.

Quit drinking the Mellinger/Teicher/Clay haterade. Use your damn brains people.

:clap:

This is all that really needs to be said. It's Gospel on this subject.

Don't feed the troll.

Again. Facts, not fiction.

Thanks for the reply.

The defense wasn't stifling by any means yesterday, but they still held the opposing team to 19 points. A offense should be able to win those games 95% of the time at home.

And you had a meltdown in multiple threads along with Oak... and you let Dane get under your skin.

So you were saying?

I bet BlackBob wishes he could have put his Uncle on ignore.

Are you a paid football coach and have more credentials than Reid and company? Do you understand what time of possession is? Do you realize the league average in 3rd down conversion is 40% while we allowed them to 68%?

Thanks for the reply.

Yes - especially when you consider that they were in position to do so. Until they blew it. It's not like they had to get there - they WERE THERE. :shake:

to not put injuries at the top is ridiculous, in my humble opinion.

No Maclin? No Houston? No MP22? Hali with half a breath left? Concussions to QB and RB1? RB2 nursing something? Starting LG out on IR? Half a Gaines? No Dee Ford? Bailey gone to IR? Howard out? and Zombo getting time?

No, No. You have it all wrong.


The defense should be flawless every game. What other teams actually expect their offense to produce?! I mean, they are simply there to not turn the ball over and set up the punter.


Offense should win these games? That's just crazy talk. LMAO

I'm not even convinced that this guy isn't a reverse Clay. There is no way he believes anything that he says.

The fact that Smith put up those numbers without his #1 receiver says enough about where the true problem in the team was yesterday.

When did he put them up? I know one thing - he put the INT on the board when it still mattered.

Please send your complaints to PFF, ESPN, and the inventor of the QB rating.