I was a Skyy Moore-on. Thought this was the year.


**** was I wrong.

I've bitched about these scrubs enough and in the end they still won a Superbowl. Move on from all except Justin Watson.

Words fail me as I try to express my disdain for Toney. We traded Sneed for a 3rd rounder in 2025. If we can get any draft pick at all for Toney, in any year at all, we should be all over it. Moore has been hugely disappointing, but could still possibly get his head out of his ass.

In thinking about it, why aren't Toney and Moore in Texas with Mahomes? Are they just not invited?

Definitely MVS.

Toney was injury prone and dumb. I didn't realise he was borderline reeruned but I knew he was stupid and I got pelted on here for saying so.

I also knew Skyy Moore was going to be a ****ing disgrace. After reading all of the hopes and lofty predictions from people on here over the summer I thought maybe because I'm relatively new to the sport (5 years) I'm not seeing it right. I won't doubt my eyes again. Skyy Moore is the worst WR I've ever seen in the NFL.

Toney and it not even close.

Got to be Moore for me. Bust draft that doesn’t appear to have talent.
Toney came to us cheap so I’m kind of whatever. But man that guy drives me crazy with his liabilities. His play would hurt us over and over.

It was definitely Toney hands down

The drops in that first game, just kept happening. It was so bad I swore it had to have been on purpose. But I remember he skipped out on training camp by having some cleanup surgery and just was not ready for game time.

Keep them away from our starters, they might spread the suckage...

A 3rd and a 6th isn't real cheap, but... Toney is responsible for us going into Buffalo and Baltimore. Makes this years Super Bowl damn special!!!

Still the biggest disappointment to me in spite of that!

Toney, easily

He got drunk on his initial success here, and decided he could just put his feet up on the desk and coast

Toney because he actually has flashed before.

I never expected anything from Skyy.

MVS is what he is.

Moore.

I think Toney is talented enough that he can bounce back. The guy missed training camp, had a disastrous first game, and spiraled from there. I can understand that (even if it was crazy disappointing).

Skyy was just a complete disappointment at every single turn. I have no faith that he’ll ever be a contributor while I’d be an aggressive buyer of Toney’s stock right now if given the chance.

I thought Skyy could do some damage over the middle of the field kind of like Edelman so I voted Moore.

I never thought Toney would stay healthy long enough to make a huge difference on the season.

Watson gave us what you would expect from him in any given season, and I knew Ross was a training camp hero and nothing more.

Toney/Moore are a wash. Toney was drafted higher (albeit by a different team). I never understood why some people thought Moore would rebound in 2023. He didn't show much in 2022. I figured Toney would be a brokedick again but he proved to be much worse even when healthy.

I'm almost tempted to pick Ross because he didn't get many chances before.

Watson shouldn't be on the list. He's a solid #3/4 receiver who made a lot of big plays in 2023 in key moments. If someone expected him to be a #1 or #2 they were asking too much.

Richie James should be on this poll.