How about what Geno would bring to the table for productivity in the passing game? Huh? The kid is damn good. It wouldn't take long for Geno to pick up in an Andy Reid offense. Also durability & escape ability to extend plays much like what McNabb could do.

Geno is more accurate

There are others that have already given you the similarities, other than skin color.

You just refuse to acknowledge them.

That being said, I compare Geno to Aaron Rodgers moreso than to McNabb, because of the accuracy.

I have said, for the dumbshits that must compare black to black, that Warren Moon is a better comparison.

I think the Rodgers comparison is pretty spot on. Too bad no QB is worthy of the pick though!!!!

Yeah, whatever. Both interception rates are low, and there's a lot of noise in those anyway. Both threw the ball a ton, and had fantastic yards per attempt. Not saying that Doege is a prospect, just suggesting that you can't really compare QBs in the Air Raid system to guys in other systems using stats alone, because the Air Raid offense is...better. A related point: how long will USC continue to use an antiquated offense? Even in the NFL, are so-called pro-style offenses on their way out?

I like to compare Geno to Doug Williams a black QB who has won a Super Bowl :D

You do know we've actually WATCHED pretty much all of Geno's throws and not relied solely on "stats"? We think he's an NFL prospect because of his mobility, deep ball, accuracy, and work ethic.

I compare Geno Smith to Tavaris Jackson

Trollolol

I'd be really concerned about that comparison if I thought you had a single functioning brain cell.

Yes, I understand that. But simply comparing his stats to Matt Barkley is unfair. Look, I hope we take a QB with the #1 pick. I'm just not as convinced as most on here that Geno Smith is obviously the best QB in the draft. Maybe he is, may he isn't. Six months ago, everyone though Matt Barkley was the guy. And no, I am not suggesting we take Barkley.

I thought Tim Couch and Mark Sanchez would be very good NFL QB, shows you how much I know -- projecting from college to the NFL is damn tough -- so many variables effect whether a guy will develop into a franchise QB. This isn't baseball where it is possible to look at a guy's minor league OPS and have a fair amount of accuracy in predicting a guy's major league stats.

Dorsey and Reid are going to evaluate the shit of these guys, and if Geno is their man, I'm fine with it. If it's Barkley or Wilson, I'm fine with it. They have access to information about unobservables that I don't, and presumably a skill set in analyzing the observables that I lack.

But if you want to second guess those guys and be a miserable Chiefs fan if they don't decide on Geno Smith, go ahead.

ROFL

I can't wait until after the combines when all of the "experts" jump on Geno's nuts. It'll be funny watching the rest of the Chiefs fans try and hop on board as fast as possible.

Same here.

I'm having a hard time picturing Geno in a chiefs uniform, just seems like we're always shit out of luck when it comes to these players.

Knowing our history and luck, I could see Geno going to the jags or even buffalo.