Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286126)

:spock:

I've yet to see Geno throw a "spectacular" long ball that really stuck out and "wowed" me. I've seen plenty long balls where the receiver had to stop, slow down, change course, to get to the ball. I've seen plenty where he's over thrown the receiver by 5 yards.

That doesn't describe "spectacular long ball" to me.

Does he have an Arm? Yes. Does he have short/mid range accuracy? Yes. Does he have deep ball accuracy? Questionable.

Can't wait to use Andy Reid fix that though.

Originally Posted by Molitoth (Post 9286136)

Omg I can tell you haven't watched shit.

Go watch the Baylor or Oklahoma games alone if you want deep balls of perfection.

Originally Posted by JASONSAUTO (Post 9286137)

You must not watch him play then...

Originally Posted by the Talking Can (Post 9286154)

jesus....just making shit up is one thing

but to make shit up and try to pass if off on this board is another

smith throws the most beautiful, accurate deep ball of any QB in college...go watch 'game tape'...****tard

Originally Posted by mdchiefsfan (Post 9286160)

Credibility lost

Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286161)

I don't want to watch 2 games to see perfection, I want to see perfection in all of them.

Did you see the Texas Tech game? In all honesty that game right there was probably the most "telling" of his strengths and weaknesses. Same for the Texas game.



I have, a 10 yard pass is not a deep ball to me. A 15 yard pass is not a deep ball to me. I honestly don't even count a 20 yard pass as a deep ball. Its when you get to ~30 yards or more that we're talking deep ball status.

And I"m not talking the total length of play here, I'm speaking specifically of the distance between the QB when he releases, and when the Receiver catches the ball.

His deep ball accuracy is certainly questionable, especially at the NFL level. This isn't college where you can just heave it up and hope your receiver can run underneath it, like you see in at least 40% of the "brilliant" deep ball throws from Geno. You have to be able to throw the ball 35 yards down the field into a window, on time, in stride. He'll have to work on his touch slightly in the pros.

Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286175)

You can't judge his deep ball accuracy based on a highlights video, you have to look at each and every throw he attempts throughout the season, throughout his career.

It has become very apparent to me that 90% of you are watching highlight videos.

Do yourself a favor, find the games where your QB has done his WORST, and watch every single pass.

Believe it or not, the "worst" games translate more accurately to the NFL than the "highlight" reels.

Originally Posted by milkman (Post 9286179)

Not even going to argue with your dumb ass.

Originally Posted by JASONSAUTO (Post 9286192)

He doesn't watch two games where it was great but did you see that one game where he was bad?


JFC.
Posted via Mobile Device

Originally Posted by DeezNutz (Post 9286191)

Well I'm glad we found someone who has watched every single pass Smith has every made in his career.

Meanwhile, I'm confident that you've seen Smith play less than most of us currently in this thread, and you're dead wrong in your analysis.

Originally Posted by DeezNutz (Post 9286191)

Well I'm glad we found someone who has watched every single pass Smith has every made in his career.

Meanwhile, I'm confident that you've seen Smith play less than most of us currently in this thread, and you're dead wrong in your analysis.

Originally Posted by JASONSAUTO (Post 9286192)

He doesn't watch two games where it was great but did you see that one game where he was bad?


JFC.
Posted via Mobile Device

Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286161)

I don't want to watch 2 games to see perfection, I want to see perfection in all of them.

Did you see the Texas Tech game? In all honesty that game right there was probably the most "telling" of his strengths and weaknesses. Same for the Texas game.



I have, a 10 yard pass is not a deep ball to me. A 15 yard pass is not a deep ball to me. I honestly don't even count a 20 yard pass as a deep ball. Its when you get to ~30 yards or more that we're talking deep ball status.

And I"m not talking the total length of play here, I'm speaking specifically of the distance between the QB when he releases, and when the Receiver catches the ball.

His deep ball accuracy is certainly questionable, especially at the NFL level. This isn't college where you can just heave it up and hope your receiver can run underneath it, like you see in at least 40% of the "brilliant" deep ball throws from Geno. You have to be able to throw the ball 35 yards down the field into a window, on time, in stride. He'll have to work on his touch slightly in the pros.

Originally Posted by JASONSAUTO (Post 9286198)

I haven't seen one thing he has debated on this forum he has been right about
Posted via Mobile Device

Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286193)

Try it, you'll lose.

Put down the koolaid, take off the rose tinted glasses, and actually watch the kids game film, not highlights film.

Originally Posted by Exoter175 (Post 9286201)

I'm dead wrong in my analysis? Highlight films are more passable than films of him at his worst? You serious? Do you know the NFL?