Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10019125)

Eh, I have been using stats today to support my beliefs as well but really all I care about is the ability to win games which I think Alex has.

That is something I have stated since day one. The only stat that matters is wins.

Sure Geno is 2-1, he should be 1-2 barring a ridiculous penalty and in the end IMO he wont have a better career than Alex and that is what the premise of this whole debate was supposed to be.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019150)

Again, to show how ridiculously dense our fanbase is.

Say anything negative about Alex Smith, get "3-0" as a response.

Mention that Geno Smith is 2-1, and get a laundry list of reasons why he shouldn't be.

Mention that the reason why AS is 3-0 is his defense, get laundry list of excuses why the offense hasn't "gelled" yet.

Pretty comical, I must say.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10019140)

You are correct, lets see how many games he wins. He can have the freebie.

And for the record he has been better than I expected especially given the team he is on.

I still think shit goes downhill very quickly.

That is my opinion.

Hey maybe I will be wrong about Geno just like you will be about Alex. :harumph:

Originally Posted by BossChief (Post 10019152)

Geno could be total crap until his seventh year and be on pace with Alex.

Originally Posted by BossChief (Post 10019152)

Geno could be total crap until his seventh year and be on pace with Alex.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019162)

Nope. He gets three weeks.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10019158)

Whats comical is you don't see the difference between a ridiculous personal foul call handing a game to the Jets and how KC has won all 3 games without anything being handed to them.


Come on man admit Geno was gifted a win. You know its true. Acting any different is disingenuous.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019160)

Key point in bold.

People are impatient and want to "win now." Would have been interesting to win now, and potentially be prepared for the future

Geno is winning now with jack and shit around him. Who knows how much better he'd look with Charles, Bowe, etc.

I personally think we'd still be 3-0 with Geno.

But God forbid I speak highly of a kid we didn't take. I should be writing him off after three games.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10019164)

Sanchez had 5 years. Started out decent and then boom.

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019168)

If you want to ignore the plays he made to even make the PF call matter, feel free.

If you also want to ignore punt returners fumbling, QB's throwing ill-advised passes right to us, opponents dropping pick sixes, feel free as well.

Goes both ways, but last I checked you said all that matters is wins.

Originally Posted by Marcellus (Post 10019172)

Insert Herm Edwards quote here - "____________________"

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019170)

What does Sanchez have to do with it?

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58 (Post 10019177)

Hey, you made the comment, can't blame me for calling you on it.